Asia (Other)

Screenshot 2020-09-08 at 4.31.11 PMBy Preetha Pillai and Vanessa Ng, CONYERS

 

The introduction globally of travel restrictions and containment measures arising from Covid-19 has significantly disrupted business, including creating logistical issues in closing corporate or financing transactions or holding board and shareholders’ meetings. This article looks at the flexible and enabling legislation in Bermuda, the British Virgin Islands (BVI) and the Cayman Islands, which provides the tools for addressing these issues.

Electronic signatures

With an unprecedented number of people working remotely, parties are exploring different methods to execute contracts and sign board resolutions in a legal and binding manner. Some of these methods are not new — for instance, scanning (or faxing) copies of “wet ink” handwritten signatures and attaching these to a document — and are acceptable under Bermuda, BVI and Cayman law, but even these methods are of little assistance without access to a printer or a scanner; hence the increasing use of electronic signatures by using encrypted e-signature platforms such as DocuSign or Adobe Sign.

The primary meaning of “signature” is the writing of a person’s name on a document in ink with the intention of demonstrating that person’s agreement to the contents. So, does an electronic signature bind the signatory to the terms of the document in the same way that a “wet ink” signature on a document would? In Bermuda, BVI and Cayman, the answer is yes1.

All three jurisdictions have enacted electronic transactions legislation that provides a framework for the use of electronic signatures and generally gives electronic signatures the same status as “wet ink” signatures. The legislation permits the use of electronic signatures except in relation to:

  • wills or other testamentary instruments (Bermuda, BVI and Cayman);
  • real property conveyances or transfers (Bermuda and BVI); and
  • deeds (BVI only).

A common theme across the jurisdictions is the reliability test that must be met for an electronic signature to be valid. The Bermuda Electronic Transactions Act 1999 provides that (a) there must be a method to identify a signatory and to indicate that the signatory intended to sign or otherwise adopt the information in the electronic record; and (b) that method is as reliable as is appropriate for the purpose for which the electronic record was generated or communicated, in the light of all the circumstances, including any relevant agreement. This is echoed in the BVI Electronic Transactions Act, 2001 and the Cayman Electronic Transactions Law, 2003, which set out what is “reliable” for this purpose:

  • the means of creating the electronic signature is linked to the signatory and to no other person;
  • the means of creating the electronic signature was under the control of the signatory and of no other person;
  • any alteration to the electronic signature made after the time of signing is detectable; and
  • where a purpose of the legal requirement for a signature is to provide assurance as to the integrity of the information to which it relates, any alteration made to that information after the time of signing is detectable.

Board and shareholders’ meetings

With the current travel restrictions and quarantine measures, physical meetings of the board and shareholders are generally not permitted for the time being. With advances in technology, companies and their directors will want to look instead at holding such meetings “virtually” — or at least by holding a hybrid meeting, originating at one or more physical locations and linked by way of video or web conferencing (or similar), where shareholders are permitted to attend online.

Bermuda, BVI and Cayman Islands law do not prescribe where meetings of the board or shareholders must be held or require that physical meetings must be held. Indeed, the Bermuda Companies Act 1981 and the BVI Business Companies Act 2004 specifically contemplate participation in board and shareholder meetings by telephone or other electronic means, subject to the relevant company’s constitution, while the Cayman Companies Law is silent on this point. A detailed review of the company’s constitution would therefore have to be undertaken to consider if the existing provisions are sufficient to permit hybrid meetings and if any amendments to the constitution are required.

Smaller companies could consider passing written resolutions of the directors or shareholders, where permitted by their constitution. Subject to their constitution, these resolutions may be executed by electronic signature and in counterparts.

Conclusion

While the Covid-19 pandemic has created many challenges globally, it has also created opportunities for Bermuda, BVI and Cayman companies to embrace technology and enable more efficient remote working conditions. Befitting their status as international business centres, Bermuda, BVI and the Cayman Islands have the legal infrastructure in place to permit companies to harness current technology to continue their day-to-day operations safely and effectively during these exceptional circumstances.

_______________________________

1. Assuming (a) there is no restriction in the constitution of the company in question and (b) this is permitted under the governing law of the document to be entered into.

_______________________________

Screenshot 2019-11-27 at 5.52.12 PM

W: www.conyers.com

 

Preetha Pillai
E: Preetha.Pillai@conyers.com
T: (65) 6603 0707

Vanessa Ng
E: Vanessa.Ng@conyers.com
T: (65) 6603 0705

Related Articles by Firm
There’s no place to wind-up like home
When entertaining a jurisdictional challenge to wind-up a foreign company with no place of business in Hong Kong, is it a material concern that alternative remedies for unfair prejudice are available at the company’s place of incorporation but not ...
Offshore Separate Portfolio Companies in the Family Office and Private Client World
SPCs and SACs are offshore limited liability companies with an added twist ... Could a SPC/SAC ever take the place of a trust?
Scheme away
Given current financial conditions in the equity markets, opportunities for privatisations abound and schemes of arrangement are all the rage again.
Shareholder rights to requisition a general meeting
Most articles of association of offshore companies listed in Hong Kong have provisions that empower shareholders to requisition a general meeting.
Offshore 2020 — themes and trends
With the first quarter of 2020 behind us, Richard Hall of Conyers Dill & Pearman’s Hong Kong office looks at the themes that are emerging for Bermuda, Cayman and British Virgin Islands entities, both in Hong Kong and globally ...
BVI court issues key decision on recoverability of costs
The decision is welcome guidance and clarification on the recoverability of costs incurred by non-qualified persons employed in BVI firms.
General meetings in the time of Covid-19
How the Hong Kong government’s regulations on group gatherings affect offshore incorporated companies.
The first red-chip listing on the SSE Star Market
On February 27, 2020, China Resources Microelectronics officially launched its initial public offering (IPO) on the SSE Star Market, becoming the first Cayman incorporated company to be listed in Mainland China ...
Registering private funds with CIMA
All Cayman entities which fall within the definition of “private fund” in the Private Funds Law, 2020 and which are carrying on business on or after February 7, 2020 have until August 7, 2020 ...
Private wealth and estate planning for People’s Republic of China citizens and residents
Driven by an exceptional period of Chinese entrepreneurship in the last decade, high-tech manufacturing, IT and fintech are now key components of the Chinese economy ...
Privy Council confirms that fair value in Cayman merger appraisal is different from fair value in Delaware appraisals
Fair value is to be determined by the Cayman Courts based on the overall scheme of the Companies Law.
What are the recent developments in offshore trusts?
Offshore trusts are used for a variety of different purposes relating to both private wealth and commercial transactions. They depend largely upon the existence of professional trustees able and willing to take on the business of being a trustee ...
Related Articles
Data collection and early case assessment for investigations
Data collection and analysis for investigations is very different to collection for discovery or review. This article discusses the differences; how Early Case Assessment (ECA) can assist and the benefits of using review technology ...
Breakthroughs in Vietnam’s securities market
Since the first promulgation of the law on securities in 2006, Vietnam’s securities market has experienced dramatical growth (roughly twentyfold in market capitalisation) ...
The rooster is on the run
The pursuit of happiness has been an inalienable right, at least in the United States, since July 4, 1776 when it originated as an “unalienable” right in the Declaration of Independence ...
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
When disaster strikes – seven lessons in handling a cyber attack
Proper preparation and planning can help organisations set out a clear path for responding to a cyber breach ...
COVID-19: Implications for International Trade and Shipping
This article considers the main legal issues affecting shipowners, charterers, traders and shipyards.
Legal innovation in BigLaw
For many people in the legal sphere, the word ‘innovation’ has become synonymous with ‘disruption’ — for others, the overuse of the word has relegated it to just another corporate buzzword ...
Latest Articles
Data Privacy in Malaysia
DFDL’s William Greenlee sets out the data protection regulatory framework in Malaysia and its recent developments ...
Cross-border transfer of personal financial information in China
Jingtian & Gongcheng partners Yuan Lizhi, Hu Ke and associate Wang Beining take us through the details of the regulatory framework ...
Amendments to three data privacy laws in Korea and the implications
By Kwang-Wook Lee, Helen H. Hwang, Chulgun Lim and Keun Woo Lee of Yoon & Yang ...