Vietnam

Screenshot 2020-04-29 at 7.34.58 PMBy Nghia Nguyen and Trang Nguyen, bizconsult Law Firm

 

On April 1, 2020, the Vietnamese prime minister issued Decision No. 447/QD-TTg to officially declare Covid-19 a nationwide epidemic. The Covid-19 pandemic, along with the application of certain preventive measures of the Vietnamese competent authorities have greatly affected most Vietnamese-based enterprises (save essential goods and services trading enterprises). Consequently, many businesses failed to properly fulfil their contractual obligations with their partners and their own employees. One legal issue raised is that under Vietnamese laws, whether they are exempted from liability for breach of the contractual obligations.

There is no single answer to this question. Whether the defaulting party could be excused from their liability due to the Covid-19 outbreak and/or the government actions will largely depend on each transaction or case in terms of space, time and other considerations.

The Vietnamese legal framework for exemption of civil liability in case of contract breach due to a force majeure event is generally similar to other countries, specifically:

  • Criteria need to be met for a force majeure event: (i) An event occurs objectively; (ii) Unforeseeable; and (iii) Could not be overcome even all appropriate and possible measures have been taken (Clause 1, Article 156 of the Civil Code 2015).
  • Where an obligor fails to properly perform its obligation due to an event of force majeure, it shall not bear civil liability, unless otherwise agreed or otherwise provided by law. (Clause 2, Article 351 of the Civil Code 2015).
  • A contract-breaching party shall be exempted from liability in the following cases: A force majeure event occurs; or A breach is committed by one party as a result of the enforcement of a competent state management agency’s decision which the parties cannot foresee at the time of conclusion of the contract (Clause 2, Article 294 of the Commercial Law 2005).
  • The contract-breaching party claiming liability exemption shall have the burden of prove (Clause 2, Article 294 of the Commercial Law 2005).

In addition, there are some notable points below in relation to liability exemption due to a force majeure event under the Vietnamese laws:

  • Force majeure clause
    Unlike other jurisdictions (especially common law system) where an affected party may only get relief from its liability due to a force majeure event if such clause has been agreed in the contract in question, liability exemption clauses in case of force majeure event under Vietnamese law can be applied without setting out in the contract, provided that the governing law of such contract is Vietnamese law.
  • Scope of liability exemption
    Vietnamese laws are silent on the scope of liability exemption for non-performance of contract in the event of a force majeure event. It would seem that all civil liabilities of an affected party such as liquidated damages, late payment interest, penalty for breach, specific performance, etc. would be excused or limited in case of force majeure event. Meanwhile, laws of certain countries limit the scope of liability exemption only to the extent of compensation.
  • Conditions for contract termination due to force majeure event
    In some countries, the law provides that if the occurrence of a force majeure event permanently prevents a party from fulfilling its contractual obligations, it would enable the affected party to request for termination/liquidation of the contract and such party will be released from their compensation liability.
    Vietnamese laws have no specific regulation on the right of the party affected by a force majeure event to unilaterally terminate the contract. Article 296 of the Commercial Law 2005 only allows the parties to extend the time limit for performance of contractual obligations due to a force majeure event and at the end of this period, the parties may refuse to perform the contract and neither party is entitled to request the compensation from the other party.

In practice, Vietnamese courts have so far had no typical cases on liability exemption for epidemic-related reasons. Nevertheless, they have accepted the exemption of civil liability in case of contractual breach due to objective reasons and/or force majeure event. Case Law No. 25/2018/AL announced on November 6, 2018 regarding the failure of deposit payment due to objective reasons is a typical example. Under this case law, the legal solution for the depositary’s violation under a deposit contract for house purchase since the house ownership certificate had not yet been issued is: “In this case, it is determined that the reason for the non-performance on the commitment of the depositary is objective and the depositary is released from the penalty”.

Given the negative impact of Covid-19 and the complicated legal issues arising therefrom, especially whether it would amount to a force majeure event to claim for liability exemption, the contracting parties should cooperate to seek a fair solution for both parties, while they should equip themselves with adequate knowledge and understanding of the governing law and applicable law as well as judicial practices related to liability exemption in case of a breach of contract due to force majeure events to well prepare for any dispute that might come.

 

Screen Shot 2019-03-12 at 5.41.37 PM

W: www.bizconsult.vn

Hanoi:
T: (84) 0 24 3933 2129
F: (84) 0 24 3933 2130
E: info-hn@bizconsult.vn

Ho Chi Minh:
T: (84) 0 28 3910 6559
F: (84) 0 28 3910 6560
E: info-hcm@bizconsult.vn

 

Nghia Nguyen
M: (84) 93 633 4499
E: nghiant@bizconsult.vn

Trang Nguyen
M: (84) 98 860 4260
E: trangnt@bizconsult.vn

Related Articles by Firm
Tightening regulations on corporate bonds issuance in Vietnam
Decree 81 is said to be an attempt to tighten and control corporate bonds issuance in Vietnam in the wake of a worrisome proliferation ...
The Law on Investment 2020
The current economic situation in Vietnam has revealed various disadvantages and loopholes in the legal framework, especially under the backbone law on investment.
Vietnam: Release of long-awaited guidance on Competition Law
The long-waited guidance on the Competition Law — the Decree 35/2020/ND-CP (Decree 35) — was issued on March 24, 2020 with effect from May 15, 2020, and casts light on certain prominent provisions of the Competition Law, such as economic concentration ...
Changes to investor selection for land-using projects under Vietnam’s Law on Bid
Significant amendments to the scope and process of for selection of investors of PPP projects and land-using projects.
Vietnam: New regulations on automobile transport business
After a long time in the drafting stage, the Government issued Decree No. 10/2020/ND-CP (Decree 10) on January 17, 2020, regulating automobile transport business and conditions for conducting automobile transport business ...
Vietnam: Sweeping reform to securities market
The New Law is said to be a radical improvement to securities market regulations in Vietnam and is expected to overcome those shortcomings observed for the past 10 years ...
Vietnam: New Labour Code taking effect on January 1, 2021
The participation in the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP) and the EU-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement (EVFTA) poses numerous requirements on the reform of laws, including labour laws ...
Legal issues on peer-to-peer lending business in Vietnam
Peer-to-peer (P2P) lending has been growing rapidly in Vietnam, along with the development of financial technology ...
Use of public property as payment in Vietnamese build-transfer projects
Under this new and favourable regulation, projects will attract more investor interest from across the region.
Vietnam: New guidance on forex management to FDI enterprises
Some significant improvements regarding capital transactions and M&A pertaining to foreign-invested enterprises in Vietnam ...
Vietnam: Tightened policy on import of used machineries, equipment and technological lines
From 2015, the import of used machineries and technological lines is subject to the Circular 23/2015/TT-BKHCN, which contains some inadequate points causing difficulties in import of used machineries, technological lines, especially those of more than 10 years old in fact ...
New law on competition takes effect
Vietnam’s National Assembly passed the new Law on Competition (New Competition Law) on June 12, 2018 and it will be taking effect on July 1, 2019, 14 years after the implementation of the Law on Competition 2004 ...
Encouraging foreign direct investment in Vietnam's education sector
One of the noteworthy points under Decree 86 is educational association, which is defined as twinning between Vietnamese private kindergartens ...
New electricity pricing and new sample of PPA of rooftop solar power projects
The number of solar power projects (SPP) in Vietnam has grown quickly in recent years, especially after the Prime Minister promulgated Decision ...
Reform of regulations on private issuance of corporate bonds in Vietnam
One of the most notable points under Decree 163 is that the requisite conditions for issuing corporate bonds have been significantly liberalised ...
Reform of regulations on private issuance of corporate bonds in Vietnam
The conditions for issuing corporate bonds have been significantly liberalised ...
Related Articles
Covering Ears to Steal Bells: Ignoring insolvency at risk of liquidation
The closest Chinese equivalent to the English idiom of ‘sticking one’s head in the sand’ is ‘covering one’s ears to steal bells’ ...
JV Compliance Issues during the Transition Period under the new FIL
On 1 January 2020, the Foreign Investment Law of the People’s Republic of China came into force ...
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Legal issues on peer-to-peer lending business in Vietnam
Peer-to-peer (P2P) lending has been growing rapidly in Vietnam, along with the development of financial technology ...
New Law firm in Vietnam
A group of lawyers from local and international law firms in Vietnam with over 17 years of transactional experience have joined forces to form corporate and commercial law firm Lexcomm Vietnam LLC (Lexcomm) ...
New procedural rules for setting up a general information website and social network
Under the Vietnamese regulations of Internet service and online information, social network is defined as an information system that provides its users with such …
Latest Articles
Watch again: “Is Covid-19 taking women lawyers’ careers back to the 1950s?”
A second chance to watch….. the opening Women In Law Dialogue Series Webinars: Asia and North America time-friendly (first aired ‘live’ in August 2020) ...
Covering Ears to Steal Bells: Ignoring insolvency at risk of liquidation
The closest Chinese equivalent to the English idiom of ‘sticking one’s head in the sand’ is ‘covering one’s ears to steal bells’ ...