Africa

Screenshot 2020-03-04 at 1.02.07 PMBy Chris Stevens, WERKSMANS

 

As if mining by its very nature is not difficult enough from a technical, financial, environmental and labour point of view, African mining companies face added pressure due to increasing community-related obligations and the general tendency of increased or creeping resource nationalism.

However, one should exercise caution in believing that these issues are unique to Africa, as the same tendencies apply in many other countries, including in South America and Russia. Mining often occurs in rural remote areas with indigenous communities. There is also a tendency for communities to mushroom around mines once a project develops due to potential job opportunities, offshoot industries and procurement for the mining operations.

There are two prime examples in South Africa where issues with the host community have resulted in delays. The first involves the Xolobeni mineral sands project of Transworld Energy and Mineral Resources (TEM), an Australian mining company. Ultimately the disputes with the Xolobeni community resulted in a high court ruling.

The applicants relied on the Interim Protection of Informal Land Rights Act (IPLRA) and the requirement that their consent is needed before they may be deprived of their land. They argued that such consent must be fair and informed. The Department of Mineral Resources did not ensure the applicants had the community’s consent before granting a mining right. The applicants also relied on international laws for their contention that mining rights may only be granted with the traditional community’s consent. The court held that having regard to the overall purpose of the IPLRA and the Mineral Petroleum Resources Development Act (MPRDA), and given the status of customary law under the South African constitution, there was no reason why the two Acts cannot operate alongside one another and that the MPRDA does not trump the IPLRA. The court held that the Minister lacked any lawful authority to grant a mining right to TEM without complying with the IPLRA.

In a recent 2018 Constitutional Court case, Maledu v Itereleng Bakgatla Resources, the court also considered that the IPLRA and the MPRDA should be interpreted and read harmoniously and that communities have a right to decide what should happen to their land, and must consent before they may be deprived of their land.

Screenshot 2020-03-04 at 1.03.41 PM

A further issue is the resettlement of communities on land over which a mining right is granted. An example of a successful relocation in South Africa is the Mogalakwena Mine, one of the most profitable platinum mines in the world. The biggest issue was the relocation of graves and an improvement in living standards.

Many mining operations worldwide have been detrimentally affected by the state’s desire that mineral reserves and resources are used to benefit the country and its population as a whole, rather than the need for returns on capital investment. Creeping nationalism is often used as a political tool to woo the electorate.

This drive towards nationalism is most often achieved by changes in legislation. For example, the Democratic Republic of Congo recently amended its legislation to extensively increase royalties, taxes and other obligations, provide for the designation of strategic metals and substantially increased royalties, and abolish clauses in mining agreements giving fiscal stability for 10 years.

Tanzania has substantially revised its mining code by imposing extra obligations, increased royalty rates and increased government participation. Local content regulations were also imposed.

Zambia and Kenya have also increased royalties, increased state participation and imposed extra obligations to the benefit of the state.

Resource nationalism is a hot topic in South Africa. Radical change was brought about in 2004 by the MPRDA, which converted the private mineral rights system into a state licensing system with state custodianship over mineral resources.

South Africa also introduced the concept of historically disadvantaged South Africans (HDSA) and a mining charter to incorporate HDSAs into the mining industry, including in respect of ownership thereof. From March 1, 2010, royalties are payable to the state on all mining operations and draft amendments to the mining legislation proposed restrictions on exports and requirements to beneficiate. At this stage there is no state participation in mining projects, but there is a state mining company which is more involved in mining operations than ever before.

Many African mining operations are successful notwithstanding the burdens imposed upon mining companies. However, a balancing act must harmonise the interests of the state, the community and the mining company. Often this delicate balance is disturbed by the actions of one or more of the stakeholders and then often to the detriment of all concerned.

 

____________________________

 

LEX Africa is an alliance of law firms with over 600 lawyers in 265 African countries formed in 1993. More information may be found on www.lexafrica.com.

Screen Shot 2018-03-13 at 1.28.45 PM

 

 

 

W: www.lexafrica.com

W: www.werksmans.com
E: cstevens@werksmans.com
T: (27) 11 535 8467

Related Articles by Firm
Africa: The effect of Covid-19 and business resilience
Companies worldwide are, or will inevitably be, affected in the short and medium-term by the coronavirus pandemic (Covid-19). Decline in commodity prices due to the falling demand in China, travel restrictions ...
Africa: Boon for investors as Zimbabwe enacts new investment promotion law
On February 7, 2020 the Zimbabwe Government gazetted the long-awaited Zimbabwe Investment and Development Agency Act (Chapter 14;37). The new law comes in against the backdrop of promoting the ease of doing business in the country ...
Opening the money taps into Africa
Akinwumi Adesina is not a name most people in Africa would recognise, yet it belongs to a man who is, arguably, doing the most to haul the continent out of a rut of underdevelopment and improve the lives of its ...
Coal-driven power train is running out of steam
The African Development Bank that it is making a surprise policy turn away from fossil-fuel investment and ploughing a new renewable energy path ...
Sun, wind and water stir up Africa’s energy mix
Obstacles to faster development of green energy abound everywhere, but the trend is clear and the momentum unstoppable.
Africa: Guinea emerging from the shadows
Recent reports from three respected international organisations sketch a relatively upbeat picture of economic prospects in the west African state of Guinea ...
AFRICA: How Nigeria is going local
Promoting “indigenisation” in the Nigerian economy was the subject of a recent Lex Africa seminar, which asked how foreign investors were forging partnerships with local players, using local content and local manufacturing capacity and transferring valuable work skills ...
Local content and participation in Ghana’s electricity supply industry
In line with the national push for a more structured approach to increasing local content and participation, the Regulations came into force on December 22, 2017 ...
One small step for Africa
On April 2 the Gambia’s parliament wrote itself into modern African history when it ratified the Africa Continental Free Trade Agreement (AfCFTA) ...
Zimbabwe’s ratification of the WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement
Recently, Zimbabwe, a member of the WTO since 1995, ratified the WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA) becoming the 139th WTO Member State to ratify this Agreement ...
African competition law developments in 2018 and the outlook for 2019
Africa is sometimes described as the “last frontier” of competition law because many African countries have only recently adopted modern competition laws ...
Blockchain, cryptocurrencies and the law in Uganda
By far the most significant headline-grabbing development in 2017 and 2018 relates to the stunning rise of blockchain ...
Tanzanian government releases Microfinance Bill
In a bid to ensure proper licensing, regulation, monitoring and supervision of microfinance business in Tanzania, the Minister for Finance has issued a draft Bill on Microfinance to be tabled in the National Assembly very soon ...
Ethiopia’s arbitration law challenges
Arbitration is perceived as one of the alternative solutions to congestion in the court system ...
Developments in competition law in Africa
At LEX Africa’s June seminar on developments in competition law in Africa, speakers discussed the increasing trend of governments to try and use competition law as an important part of their industrial policy ...
Zimbabwe holds massive potential for private equity investors
The country’s infrastructure is broken, but there is room for smart investors to capitalise on its rehabilitation.
Impact of the amendment of the Legal Guarantee of Stability in respect of existing mining projects in the DRC
The Government of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) commenced the review process in respect of its Act No. 007/2002 of July 11, 2002 on Mining Code (Mining Code) in 2012. The process eventually culminated in the promulgation by the President of the Republic ...
Mozambique is addressing economic reform in a big way in 2018
Significant strides in Mozambique’s legislation and policies could see a rapid turnaround in the country’s economic situation. In 2016, inflation peaked at 26 percent ...
Increasing importance of African regulatory issues for M&A, trade and investment
It is important to remember that Africa is not a country but consists of 54 sovereign states and a huge diversity of cultures, customs, languages, ethnic groups and religions ...
Related Articles
Covering Ears to Steal Bells: Ignoring insolvency at risk of liquidation
The closest Chinese equivalent to the English idiom of ‘sticking one’s head in the sand’ is ‘covering one’s ears to steal bells’ ...
JV Compliance Issues during the Transition Period under the new FIL
On 1 January 2020, the Foreign Investment Law of the People’s Republic of China came into force ...
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Opening the money taps into Africa
Akinwumi Adesina is not a name most people in Africa would recognise, yet it belongs to a man who is, arguably, doing the most to haul the continent out of a rut of underdevelopment and improve the lives of its ...
Change in threshold for registration as a credit provider in South Africa
All credit providers will now have to register under the National Credit Act, irrespective of the amount owed to them.
Coal-driven power train is running out of steam
The African Development Bank that it is making a surprise policy turn away from fossil-fuel investment and ploughing a new renewable energy path ...
Latest Articles
Watch again: “Is Covid-19 taking women lawyers’ careers back to the 1950s?”
A second chance to watch….. the opening Women In Law Dialogue Series Webinars: Asia and North America time-friendly (first aired ‘live’ in August 2020) ...
Covering Ears to Steal Bells: Ignoring insolvency at risk of liquidation
The closest Chinese equivalent to the English idiom of ‘sticking one’s head in the sand’ is ‘covering one’s ears to steal bells’ ...