Background: The owners of EVERRICH 8 (the Vessel), through their subsidiary Yuanland Ltd, entered into voyage charterparty with Rakha Al Khaleej International LLC (Charterers) for carriage of LPG on board the Vessel. The Charterers sub-chartered the Vessel to Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOCL), a government of India undertaking for carriage of LPG from the Port of Ras-Laffan to the Ports of Sikka, Ennore and Haldia. The owners discharged partial cargo at Port of Ennore (Ennore). The balance cargo of 20,998MT LPG was due to IOCL, Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited (BPCL) and Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (HPCL) at the Port of Haldia (Haldia). Mare Maritime Singapore Pte Ltd (Plaintiff) obtained an order of arrest of the Vessel claiming payments due under Ship Management Agreement dated October 24, 2014. The Vessel was arrested at Ennore, on August 20, 2015. The owners of the Vessel moved the court for transfer of the Vessel under arrest, from Ennore to Haldia, to discharge balance Liquid Petroleum Gas (LPG).

The issue: The primary issue was whether the vessel be allowed to sail under arrest from Ennore to Haldia, to discharge balance cargo of LPG.

The Owner’s arguments: The owners contended that the vessel be allowed to sail for the following reasons:

  • The loss and prejudice caused by the delay to the owners
  • The Charterers and the receivers of the cargo were in urgent need of the balance cargo
  • The owners could face potential claims for late delivery and/or short delivery of the cargo
  • The Vessel was due to undergo repairs at Haldia.

The owners offered to be subject to certain conditions i.e. allowing the vessel to sail with Bailiff and police personnel onboard and to bear their expenses.

The plaintiff’s argument: The plaintiff’s submitted that:

  • The proposed voyage could in all probabilities render the Vessel to sail through international waters jeopardising the court’s jurisdiction over the Vessel
  • The owners are a foreign company with the Vessel as sole asset
  • The owners falsely represented the geographical location of the Vessel to avoid the court’s jurisdiction
  • Risk of maritime liens being created enroute (result of breakdown or collision).
  • The cargo to be transshipped to another vessel
  • Alternatively, the receivers could take delivery of the cargo at Ennore or could purchase similar cargo and later claim from owners.
  • Commercial considerations cannot be grounds for allowing the application.

Decision: The court held that the application cannot be decided on prejudice created by the plaintiff and needs consideration on its own merit. Further, the court considered that value of the Vessel exceeded the plaintiff’s claim, and the argument regarding possible creation of maritime liens, rendered as baseless. The proposed cargo trans-shipment seemed unrealistic. Conclusively, the court relied on receivers confirmation that failure to deliver the cargo at Haldia could lead to depletion of stock. Further, the Indian Coast Guard confirmed possibility of the Vessel to sail from Ennore to Haldia under surveillance and if the Vessel violates any orders of the court, the Coast Guard may pursue the Vessel and direct it back into Indian Territorial waters. The court relied on a Division Bench order of Bombay High Court, in Lufeng Shipping Co. Ltd. Vs. MV Rainbow Ace wherein the court directed the Vessel ‘RAINBOW ACE’ under arrest be moved from the Pipava Port to Mumbai Port. Therefore, the court allowed the Vessel to sail from Ennore to Haldia, subject to certain conditions:

  • That an independent master-mariner board the Vessel to supervise at all times.
  • That armed guards be present on the Vessel.
  • That at all times, the Vessel reports her coordinates to the Indian Coast Guard.
  • The court accepted the owners’ undertaking to bear all expenses.
  • The owner would bear all expenses of armed guards and independent master-mariner on board the Vessel.

Clasis Law
1st Floor, Bajaj Bhawan, 226, Nariman Point
Mumbai 400 021, India
Tel: (91) 22 4910 0000 / Fax: (91) 22 4910 0099

Related Articles by Firm
Radical changes in the Foreign Direct Investment regime
INDIA- It is observed that India has the potential to attract even more foreign investment which could be achieved by liberalising ...
India's The Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Ordinance, 2015 makes major changes to the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996
The Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Ordinance 2015 gives the necessary impetus for ease of conducting arbitration in India and enables speedy settlement of commercial disputes.
Multiple lenders = multiple stamping
On August 11, 2015 the division bench of the Supreme Court of India overturned a full bench decision of the Gujarat High Court in the matter of Coastal Gujarat Power Limited v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority....
Indian patent office revokes Hoffman-La Roche’s ‘Valganciclovir’ patent
The Controller of Patents (India) recently revoked the patent granted for the anti-retroviral drug ‘Valganciclovir’ used for treating active cytomegalovirus retinitis infection (CMV) ...
Urban reforms – three urban rejuvenation schemes launched
There is a compelling need to develop sustainable and technology-driven urban centres, partly as the burgeoning urban population is creating pressure on existing cities and partly to address the growing ...
Highlights of the Companies (Amendment) Act, 2015
The Companies (Amendment) Act, 2015 (Amendment Act), which aims to amend the rigidities of the Companies Act, 2013 (Act), has ...
India - Projects, energy and infrastructure update
Including: Long-term infrastructure bonds;Smart cities mission and urban rejuvenation scheme; Railways to e-auction re-development of stations; New hybrid annuity model of PPP for the road sector; Shell set for global acquisition of BG; and IFC signs master co-operation agreement ...
The New Land Bill – ground reality
The Right To Fair Compensation And Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Amendment) Bill, 2015 (2015 Bill) was …
Prima Facie Validity of a registered trade mark in India – A strong but rebuttable presumption
The Indian trademarks law recognises both statutory as well as common law remedy to protect the rights of the proprietor of a trade mark. However, it is well-known that …
Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill passed as ordinance in India
The long-awaited Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill (the Bill) has become a provisional law in India. The Bill, which could not be passed in Parliament in its winter session, was promulgated by the President …
Need for uniform stamp duty incidence across all States of India
‘Stamp Duty’ is a tax levied on an instrument by which any right or liability is, or purports to be created, transferred, limited, extended, extinguished or recorded …
‘Make in India’ campaign: Opportunities for investors
With a vision of leading the economy towards a path of high sustainable growth, the Prime Minister of India on September 25th, 2014 launched the ‘Make in India’ campaign. Through the …
Bumpy road ahead for vehicle manufacturers in India – pulled up by the competition watchdog
South Asian markets are one of the fastest growing markets for vehicle manufacturers worldwide. However, doing business in South Asia has its own challenges. The anti-monopoly watchdog of India …
Introduction of real estate investment trusts in India
The Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) in India have been in the news for some time. The World Bank1 describes REIT as a security sold to investors for the purpose of investing in real estate. REITs …
SC Larger Bench decision in case of Kone Elevators – distinction between ‘contracts of sale’ vis-a-vis ‘works contract’
The Constitutional Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court (SC), over-ruling the earlier decision of three-member Bench re State of A.P. v. Kone Elevators (India) Ltd1, has held that the activity of manufacturing, …
Companies Act, 2013 – implications for investors
One of the recent initiatives of the Indian Government towards ensuring sustainable economic growth and improving investment climate is enactment …
India Update, inc. Medical device controls
An overview of how and where regulatory controls apply to medical devices in India. Plus: key judgements passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court; changes in corporate and commercial matters; and case laws in indirect taxation.
Related Articles
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Chinese M&A goes under the radar
There is a greater focus on smaller, more strategic deals that attract less scrutiny from government officials ...
No love for thy neighbour: Spooked government builds the Great (FDI) Wall
India has made all FDI from countries it shares a ‘land border’ with subject to prior government approval.
Latest Articles