The benefits of a contract audit


Managing contracts for the supply of goods and/or services is an increasing challenge for many businesses today, where potential overcharges, changes in scope, conflicts of interest, delays and variations in quality, among other issues, can all result in financial and/or reputational loss.Although all industries face these contracting challenges, the construction sector is particularly vulnerable given the large
value of projects, a reputation for ‘questionable payments’ and other irregularities. Therefore, it is no surprise that 75 percent of companies in the construction industry have expressed that they were affected by fraud1 in 2015.

Money can be lost through both ‘soft leakage’, due to duplicate payments and other mistakes such as formula errors in spreadsheets and ‘hard leakage’, due to fraud. The ability to check, monitor and audit financial arrangements during the course of a project, a process known as a contract audit, is essential in reducing the risk of both hard and soft leakage. For example, Kroll was recently retained by a client with a number of ‘greenfield projects’ underway in China. Although numerous resources had been deployed by our client to manage the construction project, ultimately nobody had performed a ‘deep dive’ into the amounts being charged by various contractors. An analysis of the accounts payable ledger, associated supporting documentation and selected vendors revealed areas of potential overcharge in the initial stages of the project.

Often areas of potential overcharge (whether by soft or hard leakage) on construction projects relate to the calculation and allocation of ‘overhead costs’; specifically, the components of overhead costs that can and cannot be charged in accordance with the terms of the contract and whether the charging of overhead is duplicated between the contract and any subsequent variations to the contract. In a recent matter, we identified and quantified the duplication of overhead costs in the tens of millions of dollars.

The risk of soft and hard leakage occurring in a contract can be mitigated by the appointment of a forensic accountant to deep dive into the costs and reconcile the charges back to the terms of the contract. Having a forensic accountant involved at the contact drafting stage (phase 1) and then through the delivery of the project (phase 2) in monitoring charges as they are presented by the construction company can eliminate major surprises at the point where the contract is completed (phase 3) (i.e. a new building is handed over or the goods are supplied), which can lead to a significantly smoother finalisation process. The assistance provided by a forensic accountant during each of the three phases of the contract lifecycle can help clients understand and mitigate the risk exposures at each stage.

Once hard or soft leakage is identified and quantified, the amounts can be recovered through a commercial negotiation process or a more formal dispute forum if necessary. For example, Kroll was engaged to undertake a contract audit of a construction project where we identified that the construction firm was charging a profit margin over and above what they were entitled to charge under the terms of the contract. One method employed to inflate charges was to embed a profit margin into the hourly rate of ‘cost’ for each worker on the construction project. Through forensic accounting analysis, we identified and quantified this amount, which was successfully recovered by the client through arbitration.

Given the complexities, the use of a forensic accountant to undertake a contract audit results in the costs charged being dissected, analysed and monitored throughout the lifecycle of the contract. This mitigates the risk of both hard and soft leakage, and provides confidence that amounts charged (and paid) are in line with the terms of the contract.

–––––
Endnote:
1. Kroll Global Fraud Report 2015, page 79

Email: pglanville@kroll.com
Website: www.kroll.com

Tags: Due Diligence, Due diligenceInvestigations, Investigations
Related Articles by Firm
Foreign Banks Allowed to Operate in Myanmar
After more than 50 years of banning, the Central Bank of Myanmar has issued the first final licenses allowing four foreign banks to operate in Myanmar.
Tanzanian Draft National Energy Policy of 2015
Highlights on the ongoing and upcoming industry developments with focus on the transition of the energy sector since the introduction of the Big Results Now! campaign
Mineral Rights Available in Tanzania
Overview of the mineral rights available in Tanzania, with specific focus on the various categories of mineral rights
The Legal Framework of the Aviation Sector in Tanzania
As attention turns to Tanzania’s trade and energy opportunities, the spotlight has fallen upon the nation’s infrastructure. This update focuses on the capabilities and issues of the Tanzanian aviation sector.
Oil price volatility - Offshore oil storage
Are there any legal concerns with tankers being used for floating storage?
Oil price volatility - risks and opportunities in 2015
While many companies can weather the oil price slide and volatility, some industry players face a real risk of insolvency.
India: Union Budget 2015
A bullet-point overview of changes in Direct Tax, Indirect Tax and Goods and Service Tax in India in light of Finance Minister Arun Jaitley’s first full-year Budget…
Prohibition against transfer of personal data outside Hong Kong
Section 33 of the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance (PDPO) prohibits the transfer of personal data to places outside Hong Kong, except in circumstances specified in the PDPO.
Security of payment under FIDIC contracts: more secure, for now
The High Court of Singapore recently handed down an important judgment in relation to the enforceability of Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB) decisions under the FIDIC forms of contract.
Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill passed as Ordinance in India
The long-awaited Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill has become a provisional law in India. The Bill amends the Insurance Act (1938), the General Insurance Business (Naturalisation) Act (1972), and the Insurance Regulatory and Development Act (1999).
SICC: now open for business
On Monday 5 January 2015, the Singapore International Commercial Court ("SICC") was officially opened...
Myanmar insurance update
Clyde & Co partner Michael Horn recently visited Myanmar's commercial capital Yangon and reports on the current state of the insurance market...
Launch of the online mining cadastre transactional portal
Plus, a summary of the key mineral rights available in Tanzania; and, a look at the manner in which mineral rights can be transferred.
Restrictions imposed on holders of mineral rights
This briefing looks at some of the restrictions imposed on holders of mineral rights in Tanzania by the Mining Act 2010
Draft local content policy for the oil & gas industry in Tanzania
The first draft of the long-awaited local content policy for the oil & gas industry in Tanzania has now been published by the Ministry of Energy and Minerals ...
Tanzania: Revocation of mining licences
The Tanzanian government recently announced the cancellation of a total of 174 mining licences. This mining update examines the key continuing obligations imposed by the Mining Act upon mining licence holders.
Mining Development Agreements
In this month’s mining briefing we look at Mining Development Agreements (MDAs) and the role that they play in the mining sector in Tanzania.
The Tanzanian railway system: current legal framework
The railway system of mainland Tanzania has a total track length of 3,676 kilometers (km) with two separate networks, run by two separate organisations ...
Related Articles
UAE – Dynamism in business and dispute resolution in the Gulf
With a variety of new legislation in the emirates, Louise Bowmaker of Horizons & Co looks at some of the most significant recent and upcoming changes ...
SCIA’s innovation: Optional appellate arbitration in China
A substantive appellate mechanism constitutes a beneficial complement to the finality of single-instance arbitration ...
Introducing Chinese arbitration to the world
Through open dialogue, BAC is developing the knowledge and expertise to become a leading arbitration hub among the international arbitration community ...
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Latest Articles
Ministerial Regulation removing back office services from the Foreign Business Operations Act announced
Certain back office service businesses will no longer require a foreign business licence.
Changes are coming!
Five factors to consider when reviewing your Canadian trademark strategy in 2019.
Herbies goes to Shanghai FTZ
Herbert Smith Freehills is adding local law capabilities in China through a joint operation with Kewei Law Firm.