Screen Shot 2018-01-24 at 6.48.31 PMBy Mustafa Motiwala and Pragya Nalwa, Clasis Law




Clasis Law recently represented Macquarie Bank in two civil appeals before the Supreme Court of India in the connected matters of Macquarie Bank Limited Vs Uttam Galva Metallics Limited and Macquarie Bank Limited Vs Shilpi Cable Technologies Limited, where a bench comprising of Justice RF Nariman and Justice Navin Sinha passed a judgment dated December 15, 2017 and held as under:

  1. The filing of the certificate under Section 9 (3) (c) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (the Code) is a procedural requirement and directory in nature; and
  2. The demand notices issued by the advocates under Section 8 of the Code are valid and in order.

To provide a brief background, Section 9 (3) (c) of the Code envisages that along with an application to initiate insolvency proceedings under Section 9 of the Code against the corporate debtor, the operational creditor shall file a certificate from the financial institution maintaining accounts of the operational creditor confirming that there is no payment of an unpaid operational debt by the corporate debtor. The Code states that this certificate has to be issued by a financial institution as defined under Section 3 (14) of the Code, which includes a scheduled bank, a financial institution as defined under Section 45-I of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934, a public financial institution as defined in Clause 72 of Section 2 of the Companies Act, 2013 and any such other institution as the central government may by notification specify as a financial institution.

In the abovementioned matters, Macquarie Bank had filed applications under Section 9 of the Code before the National Company Law Tribunal to initiate insolvency proceedings against Uttam Galva Metallics and Shilpi Cable Technologies. Macquarie Bank, being a foreign bank and not having an account with any financial institution as defined above, filed its own certificates under Section 9 (3) (c) of the Code, which reflected that no payment from the debtors had been received.

Screen Shot 2018-01-24 at 6.44.05 PM

In subsequent appeals before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) filed by the parties, the NCLAT held as under:

  1. That Macquarie Bank was not a financial institution within the meaning of the Code and thus the certificate filed by it is not in terms of the requirement under Section 9 (3) (c) of the Code. The said requirement being mandatory in nature, an application in absence of the certificate is not maintainable and as such deserves to be dismissed; and
  2. That the advocate/lawyer, a chartered accountant or a company secretary or any other person in absence of any authority by the operational creditor and since such person do not hold any position with or in relation to the operational creditor, cannot issue the demand notice under Section 8 of the Code.

In relation to the point (a) above, the NCLAT relied upon its order passed in the case of Smart Timing Steel Limited Vs National Steel and Agro Industries Limited and upheld that the requirement of filing a certificate under Section 9 (3) (c) of the Code is a mandatory requirement.

In the civil appeals against these orders of the NCLAT, the Supreme Court has settled the legal position and has held that the filing of certificate under Section 9 (3) (c) of the Code is not a pre-requisite to trigger insolvency proceedings under the Code. The Court has held that the filing of the certificate under Section 9 (3) (c) of the Code is a procedural requirement and is directory in nature. The Court has further held that the demand notices filed by advocates under Section 8 of the Code are valid and in order.

Through this judgment the Supreme Court has implemented the true legislative intent behind the Code and has enabled the operational creditors, especially the foreign operational creditors, to initiate insolvency proceedings against their debtors without being restricted by the procedural requirements that are not mandatory in nature. This judgment is, thus, a huge respite, especially for the foreign operational creditors, who do not have an account with a financial institution within the meaning of the Code, as now they are not restricted by the said requirement to initiate insolvency proceedings under the Code.


Clasis Law Logo






T: (91) 11 4213 0000

F: (91) 11 4213 0099

Related Articles by Firm
India going all out to woo foreign companies moving out of China
A silver lining of the Covid-19 crisis is the potential of becoming an attractive alternative to China.
Doing business and ease of doing business in India
VIDEO BRIEFING: The government has taken numerous steps to give an impetus to foreign investment, but a lot remains to be done.
MCA introduces e-form DIR-3-KYC for directors with approved DINS
This compliance exercise seems to be a checkpoint for only genuine individuals acting as directors in a legitimate capacity.
A wide net of ineligibilities for being a resolution applicant
Almost two years after the Bankruptcy Law Reforms Committee submitted its report, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code is still a work in progress.
Insolvency in India: Section 29A…
A wide net of ineligibities for being a Resolution Applicant ...
DISHA — India’s probable response to the law on protection of digital health data
Sensitisation and protection of people’s right to privacy and security of their data are the bedrock of DISHA.
The Admiralty (Jurisdiction and Settlement of Maritime Claims) Act, 2017
This much-awaited piece of legislation brings clarity to various deadlocks in Indian jurisprudence.
Metro projects likely to drive India's infrastructure sector
Metro Rail projects in India have picked up pace and are likely to catalyse substantial opportunities over the next few years.
Handling disciplinary proceedings by employers
Breach of an employment contract by an employee often results in disciplinary action leading up to termination in cases of serious misconduct.
Clasis Law Newsletter
The latest legal news from India, including recent court judgments, changes to corporate/commercial law and updates on projects and IP.
Initial Coin Offerings: Another brainteaser in the virtual currency bandwagon
The position of virtual currencies and ICOs in India remains murky.
The impact of General Data Protection Regulations on Indian companies
Extraterritorial applicability of GDPR makes it clear that these regulations will be applicable regardless of whether the processing takes place in EU or not.
ONGC vs Sime Darby consortium
An unsuccessful party cannot possibly apply for interim relief in aid of what it lost before the arbitral tribunal.
The Fugitive Economic Offenders Bill 2018
The bill aims to provide an effective, expeditious and constitutionally permissible deterrent to ensure that such actions are curbed.
Understanding The Maharashtra Shops And Establishments Rules 2018
The Act regulates the employer–employee relationship and service conditions such as hours of work, payment of wages, overtime, leave, holidays, etc.
Supreme Court gives clarity on Section 26 of the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015
In Board of Control for Cricket in India vs Kochi Cricket, the Supreme Court has clarified some issues surrounding the Act.
Delhi High Court resolves uncertainty between two conflicting clauses in contracts
The settled principle of contra proferentem has been re-affirmed by the Court in a case involving Delhi Metro Rail and Voestalpine.
India: Supreme Court update
Supreme Court refers the question to determine the liability of the consignee or steamer agent in respect of ground rent charges to be paid to the port trust to a larger bench ...
Corporate Social Responsibility
There is a growing realization among the corporates that business growth along with positive community/social impact is now an expected goal ...
India: Execution Proceedings for Enforcement of Arbitral Award
Recent Supreme Court judgement resolves certain issues and requirements ...
India: Impact of the Companies (Amendment) Act, 2017
With the assent of the President on January 3, 2018, the much-awaited Companies (Amendment) Act, 2017 (Amendment Act), which provides for simpler provisions but stringent penalties, has finally seen the light of the day ...
Voluntary Liquidation in India
Winding up under Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 ...
Strike Off of Companies in India
Over the years, many companies have been lagging behind in filing of annual documents such as annual returns, financial statements etc ...
India: Valuation by Registered Valuer
“Price is what you pay, Value is what you get” ...
India: Amendments Under Master Directions on Issuance and Operation of Prepaid Payment by RBI
Digital wallets such as PayTM, along with debit and credit cards, are expected to reduce (if not completely replace) the use of paper currency …
India: Institutional Arbitration – Need of the Hour
The need to promote and encourage institutional arbitration for commercial disputes in India ...
India: Consumer Protection
NCDRC’s ruling on ‘Voluntary Consumer Association’ under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 ...
India: Foreign Exchange Management Regulation
Significant changes for transfer or issue of security to a person resident outside India ...
India: Directors' duties and liabilities under the Companies Act, 2013
Directors must be aware of their role, responsibilities and duties towards the company and its shareholders ...
India Update for December 2017
This edition brings to our readers a featured article titled “The Tourism and Hospitality Sector 2017 — The Year Gone By!!”
India: RBI issues Directions on Peer to Peer Lending Platform
Online lending transactions are in their nascent stage in India and given the increase in peer-to-peer (P2P) lending through e-commerce marketplace it is of extreme importance to regulate such transactions ...
INDIA: Right to privacy and data protection in India
The concept of data protection and privacy has not been addressed in any exclusive comprehensive legislation in India ...
India: Protection against groundless threats under Indian IP laws
Rapidly growing awareness of intellectual property (IP) rights and a well-structured statutory regime protecting IP has allowed rights owners to assert and enjoy the limited monopolies conferred on them ...
Corporate compliance: Necessity and implication
The Companies Act of India is the primary legislation governing the functioning of companies established in India during their lifecycle....
India update from Clasis Law
Including briefings on the national food processing policy, projects and energy, and intellectual property.
RBI intervenes in patching up of Tata and DoCoMo’s joint venture
Background to the joint venture: Tata DoCoMo, an Indian mobile network operator, was set up as a joint venture between Tata Teleservices (TTSL) and NTT DoCoMo in November 2008...
Regulatory challenges for Vodafone Idea merger
Vodafone India is in discussions with Idea Cellular for an all-share merger. It appears that the intense competition the Indian telecom industry is facing due to freebies offered by the new entrant, Reliance Jio, has ...
India Update, inc: Regulatory challenges for Vodafone Idea merger
This months India newsletter from Clasis Law includes an article on the “Regulatory challenges for Vodafone Idea merger”, plus updates in Projects, Energy, IP and Banking & Finance ...
Investment conditions and restrictions for venture capital funds
Venture capital funds (VCFs) are contributing considerably to India’s economic growth. The amount of investment directed to venture capital has grown in recent years due to the pro-business environment and ...
India’s bid to become a hub for international commercial arbitration
As one of the world’s fastest-growing economies, India is a party to many international commercial arbitrations and the government is making efforts ...
Brands – Role and liability of celebrity endorsers
The marketing and advertising industry has grown as an organised industry using innovative ideas that are designed to ...
Related Articles
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
The New Land Bill – ground reality
The Right To Fair Compensation And Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Amendment) Bill, 2015 (2015 Bill) was …
India’s bid to become a hub for international commercial arbitration
As one of the world’s fastest-growing economies, India is a party to many international commercial arbitrations and the government is making efforts ...
Mauritian Company Successfully Enforces US$300 million LCIA Award in India
On 6 July 2012, Mauritius-based Cruz City Mauritius Holdings obtained a US$300 million award rendered by a London Court of International Arbitration tribunal. Cruz City thereafter sought to enforce this award in the High Court of New Delhi against its joint venture ...
Latest Articles