South Korea

Screen Shot 2018-10-23 at 12.50.42 PMBy Cho,Hyun-Jun, Lee International

 

Labour law, as it is traditionally understood, modifies conventional contract law to protect workers by recognising the difference in power between the employer and the employee, as well as the unique characteristics of labour contracts. In that sense, labour law presupposes a dichotomy between the employer and the employee. However, with the rise of the so-called Gig Economy, we see an increasing number of grey areas where that dichotomy cannot easily be applied.

Although each nation’s labour laws may contain somewhat different details, whether a person is considered an employee is essentially determined by what may be termed subordinate labour relations. In a traditional relationship in which the employee performs the designated work at a time and place specified by the employer, the determination is fairly straightforward. But if we attempt to apply the conventional standards of labour law to the temporary or flexible relationships that characterise the Gig Economy, many ambiguities arise.

Recently, the California Supreme Court adopted the “ABC test” as a tool to determine the legal nature of workers in Dynamex Operations West, Inc v. Superior Court  of Los Angeles County, a class action involving delivery drivers who were reclassified as independent contractors by their employer. Under the ABC test, a person is assumed to be a worker unless: A) the worker is free from the employer’s control or direction in performing the work; B) the work takes place outside the usual course of the business of the company and off the site of the business; and C) customarily, the worker is engaged in an independent trade, occupation, profession or business. The above ruling is seen as a ground-breaking decision more favourable to workers than earlier laws. Observers are closely following whether the same legal principle will affect wage lawsuits filed by Uber drivers both in the US and the UK.

Screen Shot 2018-10-23 at 12.54.22 PMIn Korea, as a detailed criteria to determine whether there exists an employment relationship between a worker and an employer, the Supreme Court ruled in 1994 that a number of different factors should be reviewed, focusing on substance rather than form, including (i) whether the person is governed by the rules of employment or other service (personnel) regulations; (ii) whether the person, while at work, is subject to specific and individual supervision or instructions by the employer; (iii) whether there exists any base or fixed salary given to the person in exchange for the work he/she has provided; (iv) whether the person who works is covered by employment insurance and health insurance; or (v) whether taxes are withheld by the employer on wage income. In 2006, the court instructed that those factors which an employer can control and may use to create the appearance that a worker is not an employee, such as by not withholding taxes or by not paying the worker’s four major social insurances, should be considered only secondarily as they are subject to manipulation by an employer. The stance of the Supreme Court reflects the increasingly flexible forms of employment that have been evolving and may be seen as an emphasis on substantiality in determining whether the person is an employee or an independent contractor.

The courts may not be the best vehicle for dealing with the issues raised by the gig economy. A more comprehensive solution may require the enactment of new labour laws that strike a proper balance between the workers and the hiring companies

In Germany, such changes in technology and industrial structure are recognised in the concepts of Industry 4.0 (Industrie 4.0) and Work 4.0 (Arbeit 4.0), introduced by the Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs as a framework for discussion of labour relations as a whole. The Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare of Japan has also published a report titled 2035: The Way of Working in the Future in 2016, which discusses how to refine labour laws and labour policies to recognise the evolving way that work will be performed, especially work done with fewer time and space constraints. Korea’s Ministry of Employment and Labour is also continuing to discuss related matters.

The question of how to resolve these issues is becoming increasingly difficult as a result of the changes in the industrial structure brought about by the gig economy. However, until such issues are resolved in a new legal framework, the criteria that courts have used to date are likely to continue being applied, despite the difficulty. Both employers and workers should pay attention to these issues as they define their relations to avoid, as much as possible, unwelcome surprises in the future.

 

2012_LeeInternational New Logo

 

 

 

W: www.leeinternational.com

E: hjcho@leeinternational.com

T: 82 2 2262 6288

F: 82 2 2279 5020

Tags: Employment, Labour
Related Articles by Firm
In Korea, a licensee is now considered an interested party who may invalidate a patent
On February 21, 2019, the Korea Supreme Court issued a decision making it clear that a licensee is an interested party who may file a petition to invalidate a patent for which he holds a licence ...
The value of a citizen’s participation trial
Since February 2008, pursuant to the Act on Citizen Participation in Criminal Trials, defendants in many types of criminal cases in Korea have had the right to a “citizen’s participation” trial, where a group of five to nine jurors acts ...
Korea promotes a new regulatory “sandbox” system to fuel innovation
Domestic Korean business organisations and foreign chambers of commerce have repeatedly complained about the highly regulated business environment in Korea ...
Patent licensees may file a petition for trial to seek invalidation of the licensed patent
The Korea Supreme Court ruled on February 21, 2019 that a licensee who is granted the right to practise a patent is an interested party who may file a petition for a trial seeking invalidation of the same patent ...
Tax liabilities in Korea for income generated from patents
Recently, the Supreme Court of Korea upheld a lower court judgment finding that under the Korea-US Income Tax Convention, where a foreign corporation has given a patent licence to a company in Korea ...
Preventing allegations of breach of trust for management decisions in Korea
“Is there any chance that I will be accused of breach of trust if I proceed with this transaction?” ...
Major amendments to the Product Liability Act
Since its introduction on July 1, 2002, the Product Liability Act has been enforced for the purpose of holding manufacturers, etc, liable for any damages caused to life, body or property resulting from defects of their products, according to the principle of ...
Major amendments to the Unfair Competition Prevention and Trade Secrets Protection Act
Following its amendment on April 17, 2018, the new provisions of the Unfair Competition Prevention and Trade Secrets Protection Act took effect on July 18, 2018 ...
Amended Law on designation of Chief Information Security Officer by information and communications services providers
The amendment focuses on improving the safety of information and communications networks and protecting personal information.
“Fat finger” mistakes in the Korean stock market
Attention is being focused on typos made in transactions in the Korean stock market.
Brand protection strategies for Korea
Nicholas Park, senior foreign attorney at Lee International IP & Law Group chaired a timely discussion with some of our Seoul in-house thought leaders ...
Ordinary wages in Korea
Calculation of ordinary wages in Korea can have a profound impact on an employer’s labour costs, as ordinary wages are used to calculate other benefits and compensation, including overtime, compensation for unused annual paid leave and severance pay.
Recent amendments to employment and labour laws in Korea
Amendments to several Korean employment and labour statutes were passed on November 28, 2017 and will take effect during the first half of 2018 ...
South Korea: Amendment of the Fair Trade Act
A proposed amendment of the Enforcement Decree of the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act (Fair Trade Act) was approved by the State Council on September 26, 2017 ...
South Korea: Big data ownership and regulation
On October 16, 2017, the US Supreme Court decided to hear a case in which Microsoft refused to submit requested data to US law enforcement authorities for a criminal investigation ...
South Korea: Compelling foreign-based inventors to provide deposition testimony in the US
As part of the discovery process in US patent litigation, the party accused of patent infringement will seek the deposition testimony of the inventor ...
Are shares donated to a foundation subject to gift tax?
Hwang Pil-sang, the founder of Suwon Kyocharo, a Korean daily newspaper, decided to donate money earned through his newspaper business to help students of the university he attended ...
Constitutional Court’s decision on Specific Crimes Act changes sentencing expectations
Sparked by an increase in the number of repeat offenders committing crimes, Korea has enacted a number of laws designed to prevent crimes by imposing aggravated punishment on repeat offenders...
Revised Korean law to protect privacy in smartphone apps
On March 22, 2016, Korea took steps to strengthen the protection of personal information in smartphone applications through a partial revision of the Korean Act on Promotion of Information and Communications Network Utilisation and Information Protection, etc.
Unfair competition in Korea
The Korean government has taken steps to protect trade secrets more effectively by easing the requirements for trade information to become trade secrets and by enabling ...
Hanjin Shipping’s bankruptcy: is it sailing toward liquidation?
On August 31, 2016, Korea’s largest shipping company and the seventh-largest shipping line in the world, Hanjin Shipping, filed a rehabilitation (bankruptcy) action in Korea. That filing reverberated around the globe...
Comparing liquidated damages and punitive penalties in Korea
Parties to contracts in Korea generally use two types of damages/penalty clauses to prevent breaches of contract: liquidated damages and punitive penalties. ...
The Enforcement Decree of the Act on Fair Agency Transactions
On July 26, 2016, the Korean Fair Trade Commission (FTC) made a pre-announcement of proposed legislation known as the ...
Amendment of the Arbitration Act
The amended Arbitration Act was announced on May 29, 2016. It is the first time in 17 years that the Arbitration Act has ....
Companies face restrictions under Graft Act
Following the Constitutional Court’s decision on the Improper Solicitation and Graft Act, known as the Kim Young-ran Act, ...
Major reform of Korean Trademark Law to follow international trends
The Act Providing Major Amendments to the Trademark Law (the Act) was passed by the National Assembly on February 4 ...
The right to be forgotten
One of the issues created by the Internet concerns the right to delete what one has posted on the web ...
Special act on revitalising companies to take effect in August 2016
On February 4, 2016, the “Special Act on Revitalising Companies” (the Act) was passed by the National Assembly of Korea as temporary legislation ...
The Korean government announces Guidelines on Fair Employee Evaluations and Rules of Employment to help enforce its labour reforms
On January 22, 2016, the Ministry of Employment and Labour (MOEL) announced Guidelines on Fair Employee Evaluations and Guidelines ...
New amendment to the Korean Commercial Code
On November 15, 2015, an amendment to the Korean Commercial Code (the KCC) was announced. The amendment, which will take effect in February 2016...
Status of Executives under the Labour Standards Act
Many multinational companies doing business in Korea perceive the country’s labour law as strict and heavily favouring workers. The Labour Standards Act of Korea (LSA) nullifies “at-will” employment ...
Why is a global understanding of intellectual property laws important?
Start-ups and small companies attempting to grow their businesses globally are increasingly receiving warning letters ...
Risk of issuing a warning letter to customers of an alleged patent infringer
Issuance of a cease and desist letter is usually recognised as the first step to be taken by a patentee against an alleged infringer in a patent infringement dispute in Korea. A warning letter to an alleged infringer ...
Tightened regulations on multinational intercompany transactions in Korea 2015
Multinational enterprises (MNEs) that operate or contemplate operating multinational businesses in Korea need to be aware of recent changes in the Adjustment of International Taxes Act of Korea ...
Review of the amendments to the Commercial Building Lease Protection Act
Under the previous version of the Commercial Building Lease Protection Act (the Act), a commercial tenant could lose the value of its ‘leasehold premium’ (kwon-ri-gum in Korean), which is the monetary ...
Amendment to the use and protection of credit information
The Use and Protection of Credit Information Act (the Act) was recently amended and is scheduled to take effect on September 12, ...
Use of in-kind contributions for new shares subscriptions in Korea
When investing in a company by subscribing to new shares, the investor can pay the subscription price in cash or in kind. Contributions …
Patent Protection vs. Fair Competition
There has been a significant increase in the number of cases related to the issue of whether the exercise of intellectual property rights violated the Fair Trade Act. These cases have …
KFTC amends the review guidelines on unfair exercise of intellectual property rights
On December 17, 2014, the Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC) amended the review guidelines on unfair exercise of intellectual property rights (Revised Guidelines), effective December 24, 2014. …
The latest win by Lone Star against national tax service
On June 13, 2014, the Seoul Administrative Court ruled in favour of Lone Star Funds and ordered the tax office to refund US$117 million in taxes collected on the sale of a block of shares …
South Korea – success as an FTA hub?
Koreans often think of themselves as the shrimp between whales and, as the Korean proverb has it, when whales fight it is the shrimp whose back is broken. These days, Korea is more of an orca than a shrimp, but ...
Korean court’s position on parallel importing of genuine goods
Parallel importing occurs when a third party imports genuine goods to Korea without the express permission of the sole/exclusive importer of the goods. …
Current trends with Domain Name Disputes
There have been many instances where a company, intending to expand its business into the Internet world, learns that someone already has registered and owns the company’s business name on …
Considerations in Contracting with DAPA
The Defense Acquisition Program Administration (DAPA) of South Korea is responsible for handling and overseeing projects related to military supplies and defense industry procurement. …
Foreign investment into casino-resorts in Korea
In recent years, the Korean regulatory environment has become increasingly aimed at attracting foreign investors and developers to invest into Korea and boost Korea’s tourism industry. Currently eight …
Suggestions for improving Korea’s parallel importation system
‘Parallel Importation’ refers to the importation of genuine foreign products (products covered by the trademark of a foreign company with legitimate trademark rights) by third parties, using different distribution …
The FBPA: South Korea’s Act to prevent bribery of foreign officials
Recently, several former executives of a large multinational corporation were hit with the largest civil penalty ever for individuals in a corporate foreign bribery case - each was ordered to pay US$524,000. …
Amendment to the Foreign Investment Promotion Act
The current Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act (MRFTA) of Korea generally prohibits a second-tier company (i.e., a domestic company …
Project Financing Vehicles (PFVs)
The use of Special Purpose Companies (SPCs) has become prevalent in financing large projects that demand substantial amounts of money …
Understanding the ‘5 percent rule’ for Korean equity holdings
Under Article 147 of the Financial Investment Services and Capital Markets Act (FSCMA), an investor who acquires 5 percent or more …
Liability for a Culpa in Contrahendo in Korean law in light of the Hyundai Group Case
In 2010, Hyundai Group, backed by Hyundai Merchant Marine, was named the preferred bidder for the 34.88 percent stake in Hyundai Engineering & Construction (Hyundai E&C)…
Working with ‘Inter Partes Review’
On September 16th, 2012, the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) initiated a new procedure called Inter Partes Review or …
Worker’s compensation rights and ‘Ordinary Wages’
Under Article 6 of the Enforcement Decree of the Labor Standard Act (the Labor Act), ‘Ordinary Wages’ is defined as …
Franchising in Korea: areas for consideration
Over the past decade the number of franchises launched by domestic and foreign companies in Korea has increased significantly …
Related Articles
New Decree on special preferential import/export tariffs under the CPTPP
Plus recent Vietnam updates on insurance, public investment and minimum wages.
SCA issues guidelines for financial institutions on anti-money laundering
The advent of AML and ATF guidance is a welcome step for businesses in the UAE.
Update on Stamp Duty regulating electronic transactions
A new notification requires parties who enter certain electronic transactions to pay stamp duty in cash.
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Amendment of the Arbitration Act
The amended Arbitration Act was announced on May 29, 2016. It is the first time in 17 years that the Arbitration Act has ....
Latest Articles
New Decree on special preferential import/export tariffs under the CPTPP
Plus recent Vietnam updates on insurance, public investment and minimum wages.
SCA issues guidelines for financial institutions on anti-money laundering
The advent of AML and ATF guidance is a welcome step for businesses in the UAE.
Update on Stamp Duty regulating electronic transactions
A new notification requires parties who enter certain electronic transactions to pay stamp duty in cash.