Screen Shot 2019-06-25 at 5.30.41 PMBy James Twigg and Daniel Lo, Walkers

 

Ever since the introduction of bitcoin more than a decade ago, we have seen the expansion of the cryptocurrency ecosystem, with over 2,000 cryptocurrencies in existence today and growing daily. In the race towards cryptocurrency and blockchain dominance, came the emergence of a fundraising method for crypto-founders to finance their companies, known as the initial coin offering (ICO). An ICO is a method whereby new projects sell their underlying crypto tokens/coins in exchange for fiat currencies or cryptocurrencies of immediate and liquid value such as bitcoin and/or ether.

ICOs in review

As of April 2019, over 3,500 ICOs have completed their fundraising, according to CoinLore. In 2017, CB Insights reported that ICOs raised approximately US$6.3 billion, while in 2018 the amount jumped to approximately US$19.2 billion, according to Strategy & with some of the biggest ICOs to date, the top four being: EOS (US$4.1 billion), Telegram (US$1.7 billion), TaTaTu (US$575 million), and Dragon (US$320 million). It is worthwhile to note that EOS and TaTaTu have both chosen the Cayman Islands as their domicile, while Telegram and Dragon have both chosen to domicile in the British Virgin Islands.

Despite this growth in ICO activity in 2018, the second half of the year saw a steep decline in ICO levels due to increasing regulatory concern over fraudulent offerings, leading to what the industry has dubbed the crypto-winter of 2018. In the first quarter of 2019 there were around half the number of ICO projects that have raised funds compared to Q4 2018 and there was also a sharp decline in the overall amount raised from ICOs compared with previous quarters. However, average amounts raised per ICO in the first quarter of 2019 is higher by US$2 million compared to the fourth quarter of 2018, according to ICO Bench. Crypto market participants will continue to face sustained pressure if they continue to sell ICO tokens/coins to retail investors. Many companies have been able to sidestep regulatory scrutiny by holding ICOs for “accredited investors” only. Interestingly, amid this cooling period for the crypto community, a new fundraising method has arisen that many believe will eventually completely replace the ICO, commonly referred to as a security token offering (STO).

The rise of the STO

The STO is similar to an ICO, but is generally a more developed and regulated version. The underlying tokens/coins entitle the investor with ownership rights, voting rights, dividend rights or some other incentive in exchange for their investment. Regulation of STOs is based on local security laws, including KYC/AML requirements, so each jurisdiction is able to leverage their existing securities regulations as their framework for STOs. STOs are gaining popularity, which signals a shift towards fully regulated securities in the crypto space. STOs first appeared in 2017 with two STOs raising a total of US$22 million. Fast forward to 2018 and STO activity has skyrocketed to 28 successful STOs and US$442 million in fundraising volume. To date, there are almost 170 STOs, with ICO Bench reporting that 120 have completed and 50 are continuing. The largest STO so far is by tZERO in 2018 raising US$134 million. For STOs to continue to gain institutional acceptance, key elements of the critical market infrastructure needs to mature such as regulated exchange platforms moving into the crypto space or crypto exchanges receiving regulatory approval and reliable crypto ratings and research.

Looking forward to asset tokenisation

In addition to the popularity of STOs, asset tokenisation will be a prevalent trend in 2019. Asset tokenisation describes the process of converting assets into digital tokens on a blockchain, commonly referred to as a tokenised security offering (TSO). TSOs are tokenising “things”, rather than making the token that has the characteristics of a security such as with STOs. As CoinPip CEO Anson Zeall has written, the appeal of TSOs is their applicability to assets that cannot be securitised by mainstream finance such as art, collectables and intangible goods, and assets where banks will not securitise. A TSO’s attributes mirror that of the underlying asset/security, but it does not have the same rights and claims like an STO. The benefits of a TSO include but are not limited to fractional ownership, increased liquidity of assets, lower costs and faster settlement.

Conclusion

As we start to emerge from the crypto-winter of 2018, we are seeing crypto and blockchain projects place increased attention to the maturing regulatory landscape. The emergence of new fundraising methods such as the STO and TSO is indicative of the declining appeal of ICOs. Maintaining an continuing dialogue between industry participants and regulators will be vital for the adoption of these fundraising methods going forward.

 

Screen Shot 2018-10-23 at 1.54.36 PM

 

 

W: www.walkersglobal.com

E: james.twigg@walkersglobal.com
E: daniel.lo@walkersglobal.com

T: (65) 6595 4670, (65) 6603 1699

Related Articles by Firm
The blockchain effect on investment funds
Blockchain was originally considered to be the innovative technology that only supported cryptocurrencies like bitcoin and ethereum ...
Onshore restructuring vulnerable to offshore SPV insolvency proceedings
In the prevailing economic climate, an increasing number of large corporate groups have occasion to consider restructuring their affairs ...
Venture capital flourishes in the MENA region on a strong offshore foundation
The recent announcement of Uber Technologies Inc’s acquisition of its Middle Eastern based competitor, Careem, in a cash and stock transaction worth US$3.1 billion, has renewed the spotlight on the burgeoning venture capital market in the Middle East and ...
Square pegs and round holes: Partnerships and trusts in Japanese PE fund structures
Statistics from Japan over the past couple of years regarding private equity (PE) and venture capital (VC) investment have been impressive ...
Venture capital in Southeast Asia — 2018 review
As the preeminent venture capital and private equity practice in the offshore legal arena, Walkers continues to see record activity levels in venture capital fund raisings and fund establishments in Southeast Asia ...
A review of Hong Kong 2018 listing reforms
Hong Kong has emerged as the top IPO market globally ...
Redeeming failures — Lessons from the Ardon Maroon case
The recent case of Ardon Maroon Asia Master Fund (In Official Liquidation) serves as a stark reminder that it is critical that investment funds are built on properly considered, and expertly drafted constitutional documents, including the mechanics for redemptions ...
Smashing records — venture capital and PE in Asia
Private equity and venture capital financing grew by 37.6 percent in the region.
Cayman Islands schemes of arrangement — an alternative tool for cross-border restructuring
The Cayman Islands remains one of the premier jurisdictions to implement complex cross-border restructurings.
Related Articles
Indonesia's new regulation on e-litigation
The Supreme Court aims to have e-litigation operating in all courts of first instance by early 2020.
Latest amendment to the procedure for the resolution of small claims lawsuit
The new procedure provides more optimal and effective regulation than the previous regulation.
Thailand Plus incentives under BOI
The two new incentives encourage companies to move from overseas to Thailand.
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Latest Articles
Indonesia's new regulation on e-litigation
The Supreme Court aims to have e-litigation operating in all courts of first instance by early 2020.
Latest amendment to the procedure for the resolution of small claims lawsuit
The new procedure provides more optimal and effective regulation than the previous regulation.
Thailand Plus incentives under BOI
The two new incentives encourage companies to move from overseas to Thailand.