China (PRC)

International Trade & Customs Law Bulletin

By Clifford Sosnow, Peter E. Kirby and Robin Edger, Fasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP

A second round of exploratory talks on the potential Canada-China Free Trade Agreement (CCFTA) concluded in Ottawa on April 27th, following quickly after the first round of meetings in Beijing in February. While much has been written about Canada’s and Canadian businesses’ interests in a potential free trade agreement, there has been little analysis of China’s interests. For Canadian businesses to properly understand and benefit from potential opportunities or take the commercial steps needed to mitigate risks from a free trade agreement with China, it is prudent to understand China’s priorities and motives behind its pursuit of a trade agreement with Canada.

While China does not publish official and detailed policies with respect to free trade agreements, and its government sources offer scarce information on any trade deal negotiations including the CCFTA, an analysis of Chinese language commentary, Chinese language news media and Chinese academic studies reveals that China’s top priorities for a free trade agreement with Canada currently are as follows:

  • Canadian recognition of China as a market economy
  • Promoting maximum access of sophisticated Chinese services and high-value Chinese industries in Canada
  • Liberalize the granting of export licenses on high-tech exports from Canada to China
  • Liberalize investment thresholds Canada applies to China under its net-benefit and national security foreign investment review regime
  • Increase labour mobility of Chinese workers into Canada

Each of these priorities are explained briefly below.

Recognition of China’s market economy status

Article 15 of China’s World Trade Organization (WTO) accession protocol designates China as a non-market economy for up to 15 years after accession. Non-market economy status allows WTO members to select surrogate markets for calculating the normal value of Chinese exports in anti-dumping investigations, which frequently results in high dumping margins on Chinese goods. The 15 year period expired at the end of 2016. China views the end of this 15 year period as indicating that they now have market economy status. This is not a universally held position among other WTO Members.

Some argue that the protocol simply means that the automatic or default designation of China as non-market economy ends after the 15 year period, but that particular Chinese industries can still be identified as non-market economy depending on the particular

situation for that industry. In fact, this is the current Canadian position contained in Section 20 of the Special Import Measures Act used in anti-dumping investigations to determine whether a particular Chinese industry producing goods that are being investigated is operating according to market economy principles. Regardless of the correct WTO accession protocol interpretation, this is an apparent source of concern for China and is expected to be raised in the negotiations.

Promotion of China’s service and high-value industries

China’s industrial strategy is to shift their economy from being driven by low-value goods manufacturing and exporting, towards an economy driven by the service sector, domestic consumption, and high-value industries. In its newly-announced 13th Five-Year Plan for Developing Trade in Services, China prioritizes the expansion of financial services, communications, and transportation into international markets, as well as promoting tourism and the cultural export of media. China will want these priorities addressed in free trade negotiations and better market access into Canada that what Canada currently offers China under the current WTO General Agreement on Trade in Services.

Liberalize granting of licenses on high-tech exports

Chinese government officials have stated publicly that a high priority for them will be increasing the scope of exchanges with Canada in the respective high-tech sectors. In the week prior to the second round of discussions, Chinese Premier Li Keqiang urged Prime Minister Trudeau to liberalize the granting of export permits to Canadian high-tech exporters. China’s Ambassador to Canada echoed this sentiment in a recent speech in Montreal, specifically noting that technological cooperation between the two countries is not an issue of national security. China believes that Canada has been indicating to Canadian high-tech exporters that their applications for export licenses to China may be refused. China would like this changed and is expected during free trade negotiations to place a priority on Canada committing to more readily grant export permits for high-tech items.

Liberalization of foreign investment regime

Under the Investment Canada Act Chinese state-owned enterprises (SOEs) are subject to restrictive rules governing proposed acquisitions , including the opaque “net benefit” test. This also includes the application of the national security review. Outward investment is a priority for China, since it is interested generally in gaining expertise and technologies, and consider acquisitions to be an effective means to achieve this goal.

The most notable Chinese investment, which was in the Canadian technology and triggered a national security review, was the 2015 acquisition of a Montreal-based military technology firm ITF Technologies by O-Net Communications, a Hong Kong company of Chinese background. This transaction was not permitted initially, but then reversed last December. While the Chinese government may consider the reversal of the decision as a signal that Canada is open to Chinese investment in a previously blocked sector, it will be a key priority for China to minimize any investment thresholds that the Chinese government considers are significant barriers to investments from Chinese SOEs.

Labour Mobility

Canada’s temporary foreign worker program has long been criticized by the Chinese business community in Canada as being overly restrictive. In the free trade agreement between China and Australia, which is the most comprehensive trade deal China has signed with a major Western country, Chinese companies who invest over AU$ 150 million are allowed to bring in temporary migrant workers to Australia without local labour market testing. It will likely be a priority for China to address these concerns in the CCFTA negotiations.

Conclusion

Much has already been done to lay the groundwork for the deeper bilateral economic relationship between Canada and China. While the negotiation and ratification of CCFTA won’t be a short process and the potential trade deal will remain controversial for some, free trade talks appear to be well-received by the Chinese and Canadian business communities. As these talks are advancing quickly, time is of the essence for Canadian businesses who see either potential opportunities or risks to be mitigated to understand the legal options available to incorporate commercial interests into the CCFTA. It is also important to understand how to communicate these interests to the federal, provincial, or Chinese governments in order to have them optimally reflected during trade talks and in the Agreement. For Canadian businesses, understanding not just Canadian goals in a free trade agreement, but also Chinese objectives, is integral to protecting important commercial interests and potential opportunities arising from trade between the two countries.

*The authors gratefully acknowledge the helpful assistance of Ms. Yufei Luo.

© 2017 Fasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP

Tags: Canada, China, FTA
Related Articles by Firm
New transparency registry for all private BC companies in the offing
If the bill comes into force it will have far reaching compliance consequences for all private BC companies.
Privacy Commissioner of Canada reverses position on transfers of personal information for processing
The Commissioner has made a surprising reversal of its long-standing position on the transfer of personal information.
Changes are coming!
Five factors to consider when reviewing your Canadian trademark strategy in 2019.
The Canadian gig economy: Embracing the future of work
Instead of quashing models that have the potential to empower the workforce, better protections for gig workers are needed.
A closer look at Canada’s budget
Fasken’s team examines important budget 2019 measures — some which made headlines, and others that should not escape notice.
Selected tax measures in Canada's 2019 federal budget
The budget contains significant proposals to amend income and excise taxes, while also providing updates on previously announced tax measures and policies.
OSFI issues advisory on technology and cyber security incident reporting
The Advisory reflects the fact that OSFI is very focused on this increasingly significant area of risk.
Health Canada pushes for safer medical devices
The announcements foreshadow significant near-term changes to Canada's medical device regulatory regime.
USMCA impact on communications industries
How the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement affects telecommunications, broadcasting and digital trade.
Surprise changes seek to modernise Canadian trademarks law and practice
This bulletin looks at key proposed changes to trademark law in Canada.
Time limits for retaining information about employees
Retention of personal information carries various obligations, particularly in terms of access to the information and confidentiality.
Further hurdles for regulatory approval of notifiable mergers in South Africa
On July 12, the Competition Amendment Bill was introduced in Parliament, substantially revising the earlier version of the Bill.
Hitting the sweet spot: Regulation of sweetened alcoholic beverages
Health Canada issued a notice of intent to restrict the amount of alcohol in highly sweetened alcoholic beverages.
Significant changes proposed to Canada’s AML/ATF regime
The Proposed Regulations are wide ranging and include a number of substantive changes as well as technical amendments.
Canada: Privacy commissioner issues key guidelines for consent and inappropriate data practices
Important guidance documents issued in respect of activities regulated pursuant to the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act ...
Cybersecurity risks for directors and officers
The cybersecurity field is ripe for affected stakeholders to test claims that directors and officers have failed to discharge their duties.
Cybersecurity Risks for Directors and Officers
Directors and officers in Canada face increased risk of personal liability and threats to job security in relation to cybersecurity...
Proposed changes to Canada's anti-money laundering and anti-terrorist financing regime
A consultation paper released in February could potentially have broad implications for Canada's AML/ATF regime.
Bill 148 Update: Scheduling and the three-hour rule
The Fair Workplaces, Better Jobs Act, 2017 makes significant changes to the Employment Standards Act, 2000.
Does your non-competition clause really protect you?
Or does it merely offer the illusion of protection? What you need to know about the validity and enforceability of a non-competition clause.
Canada: Selected Tax Measures in the Federal Budget 2018
Canada's 2018 Federal Budget contains significant proposals to amend the Income Tax Act and the Excise Tax Act while also providing updates on previously announced tax measures and policies ...
Expect the Intersection of Privacy and AI in 2018
We must consider how to regulate, or at least control, the use of artificial intelligence at different levels ...
Energy Licences and Approvals in Canada
Update on Directive 067: Eligibility Requirements for Acquiring and Holding Energy Licences and Approvals ...
Canada to Revise Tax Voluntary Disclosures Program
Effective March 1, 2018: New Regime will Result in Limited Relief for Certain Taxpayers Disclosing Errors and Omissions ...
Canada: New CASL Ruling
CRTC Provides Guidance on B2B Messaging and the Due Diligence Defence ...
Corporate Parent Liability: Litigation Risks for Resource Companies
Traditionally, parent companies have been considered legally distinct entities and thus immune from the actions of their subsidiaries, a concept described as the “corporate veil”. This position is now being challenged ...
Canada: No Duty to Consult Triggered by Omnibus Changes to Environmental Laws
In Canada (Governor General In Council) v. Courtoreille, 2016 FCA 311, the Federal Court of Appeal found that the federal government did not owe a duty to consult when it developed and implemented changes to environmental legislation through two omnibus bills ...
The Global Reach of Canadian Privacy Law
Federal Court Issues Landmark Ruling in Globe24h ...
Temporary Foreign Workers in Canada: Employer Compliance Rules
The regulations that govern applications for work permits provide a very strict framework for employers who hire temporary foreign workers in Canada ...
Canada is Open for Business
Trump and the Changing Political Landscape in the US ...
Primer on Procurement Rules in the New Canadian FTA
Fasken Martineau Releases Primer on Procurement Rules in the New Canadian Free Trade Agreement ...
Canada: Donald Trump, Paris and the Climate Policy Two­-Step
Will the U.S. withdrawal from the Paris Agreement fundamentally alter Canada's course?
Canada: New Authorities under Vanessa's Law
On June 18, 2016, the Federal Department of Health published a Notice of Intent to amend the Food and Drug Regulations and the Medical Devices Regulations to implement key authorities under Vanessa's Law...
Canada: Consultation on New Health Regs for Self-Care Products
Health Canada is seeking consultation on new standards for self-care products, over-the-counter drugs, natural health products and cosmetics ...
Private right of action under Canada’s Anti-Spam Law
As of July 1, 2017, individuals and organizations will be entitled to institute a "private right of action" before the courts against those that contravene certain provisions of Canada's Anti-Spam Law ...
New Federal Consumer Protection Regime for Bank Customers
Canada: The government has introduced a bill which proposes to create a comprehensive federal consumer code and strengthen federal jurisdiction over provincial jurisdiction with respect to products and services of banks.
Canada: Alberta's Renewable Electricity Program
Alberta released details of the Renewable Electricity Program to accelerate the development of renewable power generation through a competitive bid process.
Certainly Uncertain: Construction Trusts after Iona in Canada
A recent decision clarifies the law regarding provincial statutory trusts in the insolvency context, particularly in the construction sector.
The Fight against Climate Change and the Overhaul of Canada's Environment Quality Act
A bill allows government to require a "climate test" from a project proponent.
Health Canada Is Cracking The Whip On Advertising Violations
On January 21, 2016, various hospitals, natural health product manufacturers, physicians and pharmaceutical companies found themselves specifically named by Health Canada in a published list of health product advertising complaints ...
Canada: New Strategic Plan for the Patented Medicines Prices Review Board
The Strategic Plan comprises a fresh vision, a revised mission statement and four new strategic objectives ...
Transport Canada Promises New Drone Regulations
Increase in popularity has had a direct effect on risks involved for the safe use of regular aircraft ...
N. America: Northern Gateway Pipeline
Province must consult and decide but may impose conditions
Canada: Tinkering with Title - Don’t Get Caught by Surprise
The Mining Amendment Act 2015 proposes a new electronic mining lands administration system in Ontario.
New Lobbyists’ Code Will Restrict Dealings with Canada’s Federal Government and Agencies
Canada's new Lobbyists' Code of Conduct will significantly restrict the activities of lobbyists and others seeking to influence federal decision making.
Righting a Wrong: Canadian Regulators Improve the Rights Offering Regime
Canadian regulatory authorities recently overhauled how prospectus exempt rights offerings are to be conducted going forward.
A change of role for a legal representative under the new Clinical Trials Regulation 536/2014?
The roles and responsibilities of the legal representative set out under Clinical Trials Directive 2001/20/EC are likely to change under the new Clinical Trials Regulation 536/2014.
Historic Court of Appeal Decision in Dunkin' Brands: Three Lessons for Franchisors in Canada
The Quebec Court of Appeal has specified the intensity of the franchisor's implied obligations in what is the most significant franchise case in Québec since 1998.
New Compliance Form and Fee for Employers of Foreign Work Permit Applicants in Canada
Employers whose foreign employees must apply for a work permit or extension should be aware of a new Compliance Form and Compliance Fee that they must submit before the person applies for the work permit in Canada.
Use of Trademarks As Metadata & #Hashtags in Canada
A recent decision of the Federal Court of Canada provides guidance on the proper use of IP in this digital world that brand owners need to know now.
Claims that Involve a Fixed Dosage and Schedule Can Constitute Patentable Subject Matter
The Canadian Intellectual Property Office has issued a revised guidance which provides clear instructions on how to approach medical use claims and determine whether such claims are eligible for patent protection.
The Application of the Bhasin Principle of Good Faith in Canada: An Early Example
A recent decision from the Supreme Court of British Columbia provides an early example of how courts will apply the general principle of good faith in Canada.
The TPP Agreement: A Canadian Business Perspective
The TPP will impact goods access and other aspects of Canadian businesses.
Foreign Corruption and the Integrity Framework in Canada: A Difficult Corporate Board Dilemna
Canada's Integrity Framework raises difficult choices for corporate board directors and management regarding voluntary disclosure of prior foreign corrupt activity of an acquired company.
Canada-EU Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement Negotiation Completed: Additional Protection for Innovative Pharmaceutical Products
If ratified, key intellectual property provisions in the Canada-EU trade pact will provide additional protection for innovative pharmaceutical products.
An Update on the Proposed EU Revisions to the Regulation of Medical Devices
The proposed European regulatory regime will merge the directives on Medical Devices and Active Implantable Medical Devices into a single regulation and wholly replace the current regulation on In Vitro Diagnostic Medical Devices.
UK FCA consults on requirements for reports on payments to government
While Canada does not currently have a reporting regime for payments to governments, a process is underway to ensure that a regime is implemented in the near future.
Trademark Use: an Important Shift in Canada
Bill C-31, which was given royal assent on June 19, 2014, will eliminate the requirement that a trademark be used in order to be registered in Canada.
Intellectual Property Protection - Industrial Designs
Many companies will consider the availability of and merits of seeking patent and/or trade-mark registration. However, one form of IP protection that is often overlooked is an industrial design registration.
Protocol to Amend the Canada-UK Tax Treaty
The Canada-United Kingdom Tax Convention was amended with the signing of a protocol on July 21, 2014. This article will describe some highlights of the Protocol and comment on the impact of these provisions on cross-border tax issues between Canada and the ...
The end of the Canadian "iPod Tax" saga
The "Certain Televisions Remission Order" confirms that, in fact, there is not now, and never actually was, "tax" on "iPod" imports to Canada.
Updating Canadian Trademark Filing & Registration Strategies
Here are some key trademark filing strategies for avoiding or minimizing the potential impact of recent amendments to the Canadian trademark landscape.
The Canadian insurance M&A environment
There have been a significant number of insurance company M&A transactions in the Canadian market in recent years, a trend expected to continue. Fasken Martineau DuMoulin have surveyed the acquisition agreements from these transactions and analysed ...
Merger control and foreign investment review in Canada
Fasken Martineau DuMoulin’s Huy Do and Jack Yu1 write that acquisitions of, or investments in, Canadian businesses can give rise to merger control and foreign investment reviews. ...
Related Articles
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Power struggles – the rise of labour unrest in China
Matthew Durham of Winston & Strawn discusses the delicate balancing act currently faced in China that is employment. He sheds light on methods used by each side in the struggle for power and gives ...
Latest Articles