China (PRC)

By Nick Ferguson

A Chinese court has moved to block the sale of iPhones in China as part of the long-running global legal battle between Qualcomm and Apple.

The Fuzhou Intermediate People’s Court in China granted Qualcomm’s request for two preliminary injunctions against four Chinese subsidiaries of Apple, ordering them to immediately cease infringing on two Qualcomm patents through the sale in China of several iPhone models — from the 6S to the X — according to a statement released by the chipmaker.

“We deeply value our relationships with customers, rarely resorting to the courts for assistance, but we also have an abiding belief in the need to protect intellectual property rights,” said Don Rosenberg, general counsel for Qualcomm. “Apple continues to benefit from our intellectual property while refusing to compensate us. These court orders are further confirmation of the strength of Qualcomm’s vast patent portfolio.”

Erick Robinson, former director of patents in Asia for Qualcomm and owner of ChinaPatentBlog, described the development as “groundbreaking” on LinkedIn. “Because it is a preliminary injunction [PI], the injunction is not stayed pending appeal. Apple is entitled to file for administrative retrial of the PI ruling before the same court, but the chance of reversal is very slim.”

The injunction has little effect on Apple at the moment as it applies to phones running an outdated operating system, iOS 11, which was current at the time of filing, but has been superseded by iOS 12. However, Robinson says that Qualcomm may be able to move quickly to include the latest version of iOS.

The two patents, which Qualcomm says were previously found to be valid by the Chinese patent office, enable consumers to adjust and reformat the size and appearance of photographs, and to manage applications using a touch screen when viewing, navigating and dismissing applications on their phones.

In a statement, Apple told Reuters: “Qualcomm’s effort to ban our products is another desperate move by a company whose illegal practices are under investigation by regulators around the world.”

The two companies have been suing each other back and forth in the US, EU, UK and China. Apple has claimed that Qualcomm is charging excessive royalties for its technology and has ceased paying as it awaits the outcome of litigation, while Qualcomm has counterclaimed that Apple is infringing its patents (as in the Fuzhou case) and broke a software agreement by providing sensitive information about Qualcomm’s products to rival chipmaker Intel.

The Federal Trade Commission is also suing Qualcomm in an antitrust case that argues the chipmaker has not made its technology available in a fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory manner.

Qualcomm is celebrating a victory in Fuzhou this week, but the ultimate outcome of its global disputes may be that it is forced to license its technology to Intel and renegotiate terms with manufacturers — and none of that is likely to be news it wants to celebrate. But it could be good news for consumers.

Lian De law firm is reportedly representing Qualcomm, led by Jiang Hongyi, and Fangda is advising Apple.

Tags: China, Intellectual Property, Technology, Telecoms
Related Articles by Firm
Clasis Law (India) Newsletter August 2015
Analysis of the revocation of a company's drug patent and other key court rulings and updates on corporate and commercial matters
Foreign Banks Allowed to Operate in Myanmar
After more than 50 years of banning, the Central Bank of Myanmar has issued the first final licenses allowing four foreign banks to operate in Myanmar.
Tanzanian Draft National Energy Policy of 2015
Highlights on the ongoing and upcoming industry developments with focus on the transition of the energy sector since the introduction of the Big Results Now! campaign
Mineral Rights Available in Tanzania
Overview of the mineral rights available in Tanzania, with specific focus on the various categories of mineral rights
The Legal Framework of the Aviation Sector in Tanzania
As attention turns to Tanzania’s trade and energy opportunities, the spotlight has fallen upon the nation’s infrastructure. This update focuses on the capabilities and issues of the Tanzanian aviation sector.
Oil price volatility - Offshore oil storage
Are there any legal concerns with tankers being used for floating storage?
Oil price volatility - risks and opportunities in 2015
While many companies can weather the oil price slide and volatility, some industry players face a real risk of insolvency.
India: Union Budget 2015
A bullet-point overview of changes in Direct Tax, Indirect Tax and Goods and Service Tax in India in light of Finance Minister Arun Jaitley’s first full-year Budget…
Prohibition against transfer of personal data outside Hong Kong
Section 33 of the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance (PDPO) prohibits the transfer of personal data to places outside Hong Kong, except in circumstances specified in the PDPO.
Security of payment under FIDIC contracts: more secure, for now
The High Court of Singapore recently handed down an important judgment in relation to the enforceability of Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB) decisions under the FIDIC forms of contract.
Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill passed as Ordinance in India
The long-awaited Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill has become a provisional law in India. The Bill amends the Insurance Act (1938), the General Insurance Business (Naturalisation) Act (1972), and the Insurance Regulatory and Development Act (1999).
SICC: now open for business
On Monday 5 January 2015, the Singapore International Commercial Court ("SICC") was officially opened...
Myanmar insurance update
Clyde & Co partner Michael Horn recently visited Myanmar's commercial capital Yangon and reports on the current state of the insurance market...
Launch of the online mining cadastre transactional portal
Plus, a summary of the key mineral rights available in Tanzania; and, a look at the manner in which mineral rights can be transferred.
Restrictions imposed on holders of mineral rights
This briefing looks at some of the restrictions imposed on holders of mineral rights in Tanzania by the Mining Act 2010
Draft local content policy for the oil & gas industry in Tanzania
The first draft of the long-awaited local content policy for the oil & gas industry in Tanzania has now been published by the Ministry of Energy and Minerals ...
Tanzania: Revocation of mining licences
The Tanzanian government recently announced the cancellation of a total of 174 mining licences. This mining update examines the key continuing obligations imposed by the Mining Act upon mining licence holders.
Mining Development Agreements
In this month’s mining briefing we look at Mining Development Agreements (MDAs) and the role that they play in the mining sector in Tanzania.
The Tanzanian railway system: current legal framework
The railway system of mainland Tanzania has a total track length of 3,676 kilometers (km) with two separate networks, run by two separate organisations ...
Related Articles
Allen & Gledhill agrees Indonesia alliance
The Singapore firm has agreed a strategic alliance with Soemadipradja & Taher.
The search is on for genuine client service-focused legal providers
Submissions for the In-House Community Visionary Client Service Legal Providers Awards, 2018 are now open!
Axiom appoints new Asia-Pacific general manager
The alternative legal services provider has hired Fitbit’s Yolanda Chan.
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Legal avenues for foreign investors to participate in China’s non-performing loans market
In the current economic climate, the ratio of non-performing loans (NPL) in commercial banks continues to grow in China....
MALAYSIA: Managing risks along China’s belt and road initiative
China’s belt and road initiative (BRI) involves Chinese companies investing in or with companies in the belt-and-road countries ...
Latest Articles
Australia courts Asian markets — and capital
Deepening financial and trade ties are solidifying the country's role in the region.
Federal Penal Code amendments
The amendments are designed to make the UAE's Penal Code consistent with other recent federal legislation and current federal enforcement policies.
Clifford Chance discusses its Singapore innovation lab
We speak to Kai Niklas-Schneider, managing partner of Clifford Chance, about its newly launched Create+65 Innovation Lab in Singapore.