Rest of the World

SF-UAE

 

Screen Shot 2019-03-13 at 12.54.07 PMBy Chatura Randeniya and Nazim Hashim of  Afridi & Angell

 

Email: crandeniya@afridi-angell.com
Email: nhashim@afridi-angell.com

 

While the changes are welcome, they put pressure on litigants to plead their cases within relatively short time periods.

 

Significant changes to the UAE’s Federal Law No 11 of 1992 (the Civil Procedure Code) came into effect on February 16, 2019. These changes were introduced through regulations issued under the Civil Procedure Code (the Regulations).

The Regulations (in all, 193 articles) address a wide array of litigation procedures. Some of the Regulations codify practices already observed by the UAE Courts. In this article, we set out a high-level overview of some of the Regulations that impact both litigants and practitioners alike. Unless otherwise stated, the Article numbers refer to the Regulations.

Service of process
According to the Regulations, a court may permit a party or its attorney to serve process. Process can be served between 7am and 9pm, unless served electronically, in which case the time limits do not apply. Process may be served by voice or video calls, text messages, fax or any other alternative means determined by the Minister of Justice. Importantly, Article 5 provides that if the official language of the defendant is not Arabic, the plaintiff is required to provide an official translation of the court notice in English.

Service on parties domiciled abroad may be effected through “technological means, or private companies and offices, or as otherwise agreed between the parties”, and if service cannot be so effected, process will be served through diplomatic channels.

Screen Shot 2019-03-13 at 12.55.45 PMRegistration of cases
A Statement of Claim/Plaint should include the details of the defendant(s) including information regarding the defendant’s identification number, which is applicable with respect to individual defendants. The practice of the Dubai Courts with respect to corporate defendants is to require a copy of the defendant’s trade licence at the time of registering the case. It is therefore of practical significance that parties have copies of their counterparties’ ID and/or licensing documents with them, and obtaining such documentation should form part of best practice when entering into transactions.

Certain Regulations are evidently intended to speed up litigation procedures. Article 18, for example, provides that the period allowed for the defendant to appear in the Case Management Office or the court following registration of the case is 10 days, which may be reduced to three days. Where summary claims are concerned (such as applications for provisional attachment) this period is 24 hours, which may be reduced to one hour on the condition that notice is served on the defendant personally. While Article 18 goes on to carve out an exception for maritime claims, the scope of the exception is currently unclear.

Proceedings in the UAE Courts are commenced by filing the plaint and supporting evidence (electronically or in person) with the relevant court. Thereafter, the Case Management Office of the court will fix the court fee payable, and complete the registration of the case upon receiving payment and completing any documentary requirements which may be identified by the Case Management Office. Given that there can be a considerable passage of time between filing the plaint and completing the registration in some instances, this led to uncertainty regarding the date on which action was commenced, which is an important consideration in determining whether time bars and other time related deadlines under law have been complied with. Article 19 clarifies that the date of registration is deemed to be the date on which the case was submitted to the court system, and not the date on which the registration of the case is completed.

Assessment of Case Value
Assessment of case value is an important practical consideration, as it has a bearing on jurisdiction, appeal thresholds, and of course the court fees payable by a plaintiff. Article 23 provides that minor circuits (as set out in Article 30(1) of the Civil Procedure Code) will have jurisdiction over civil, commercial and labour claims not exceeding Dh1 million (US$272,000) in value (the threshold previously being Dh500,000), and counterclaims asserted in such cases irrespective of the value of the counterclaim. Decisions made by the minor circuit court in labour cases valued at no more than Dh20,000 and in all other cases valued at no more than Dh50,000 may not be subject to appeal. The current threshold is Dh20,000 for all types of cases. The threshold (in terms of value) for appealing a judgment of the Court of Appeal to the Court of Cassation is Dh500,000. The current threshold is Dh200,000. Article 25 contains provisions for assessing case values in various types of disputes. For example, an action for the dissolution of a company and appointment of a liquidator is valued based on the company’s capital at the time of filing action.

Screen Shot 2019-03-13 at 12.56.10 PMConduct of Proceedings
Certain claims may now be disposed of with only one hearing by a minor circuit court (Article 22). These claims include civil and commercial claims not exceeding Dh100,000 and claims for wages and salaries not exceeding Dh200,000. The Case Management Office is required to fix a case which is to be disposed of under Article 22 for its first hearing within 15 days of the date of registration of the case, and this may be extended only once with an additional 15 days by the judge supervising the matter. Article 22 does not apply to cases in which the State is a party.

Denying documents on the basis that they are copies (based on Article 9(2) of the Federal Law No 10 of 1992) is a position commonly adopted by parties, particularly defendants. Denying documents simply on the basis that they are copies will however no longer be acceptable, and the party seeking to deny documents will also be required to maintain that such documents are “invalid” or were not in fact authored by the party to whom they are attributed to (Article 20). A party that has denied documents and the court finds that the party’s denial was without justification may be subject to a fine of between Dh1,000 to Dh10,000. Importantly, the court may inform the authorities regulating the legal profession in the UAE of the fine, and thus impacts the advocates having conduct of litigation. Fines for frivolous denials of documents are not new, however its codification is a welcome development.

The efficient conduct of litigation is a recurring theme in the Regulations. The Regulations require parties to plead their cases as completely as possible at the hearing before the Case Management Office (ie, before the matter is transferred to a court). If the plaintiff or the defendant submits a document in a subsequent session which requires the court to adjourn the matter, and the court is of the view that the document could have been submitted at the first hearing, the court may penalise the party submitting the document with a fine between Dh2,000 to Dh5,000. A party may however produce documents in response to the defences and/or incidental demands of the other party without threat of sanction. A court may allow the parties to submit documents, submissions and new evidence, and to amend the relief sought and assert counterclaims that they were unable to submit to the Case Management Office. However, the court at its discretion may deny such submissions if the court is of the view that they could have been made to the Case Management Office.

Article 37 provides that a hearing may not be adjourned more than once for the same reason attributable to a party in the absence of a valid excuse. Where such a valid excuse exists, the second adjournment shall not exceed two weeks. Pursuant to Article 48, judgment must be issued within a month of pleadings being concluded.

Costs and fines for malicious prosecution/defence
While the law and the Regulations provide that the court may award costs, in practice the UAE Courts do not award legal costs, except in a token sum. Court fees and expert’s fees are however recoverable by a successful plaintiff. Article 56 provides that even a party that is successful on the merits of the case may be required to bear a portion of the expenses if that party has, among other things, caused any “futile expenses” or did not disclose documents that could have disposed of the matter to its opponents. A party that submits a malicious motion, plea or defence may be subject to a fine of between Dh1,000 and Dh10,000 (Article 58).

Screen Shot 2019-03-13 at 12.56.32 PMPayment Orders
Articles 62 through 68 set out provisions with respect to Payment Orders. Payment Orders are not new and the relevant provisions can be found in Articles 143 to 149 of the Civil Procedure Code. Payment Orders may be applied for by a creditor who has a claim for a fixed amount of money or a movable of a known type and quantity, and where the creditor’s right is confirmed. The Regulations enable the possibility of confirmation by reference to electronic sources, as well as the option of applying for a Payment Order where the subject of the claim is the execution of a commercial contract, or in case the creditor’s entitlement arises out of a commercial instrument. Pursuant to Article 63, the creditor is required to demand payment from the debtor and grant at least five days to make payment. If payment is not received, a Payment Order may be applied for. The application must include the details required of a Statement of Claim/Plaint, and have the proof of the debt and evidence of the demand for payment attached thereto. The order should be determined within three days of the application being filed. If the application is denied, the judge is required to provide reasons. Prior to the Regulations, there was no requirement for the judge to provide reasons. A Payment Order may be appealed within 15 days by the debtor, and the court is required to determine the appeal within a week from the date of registration.

An application for a Payment Order does not preclude the party from seeking provisional relief under the relevant provisions of the Civil Procedure Code.

Enforcement of foreign judgments and awards
Article 85 provides that an application to enforce a judgment or order of a foreign court shall be made to an execution judge, and that the judge is required to make his decision within three days. The execution judge is required to verify the following before issuing the decision:

  • that the UAE Courts do not have exclusive jurisdiction over the matter;
  • that the judgment or order has been issued by an authorised court under the law of the relevant foreign jurisdiction;
  • that the parties to the foreign proceedings have been summoned and represented;
  • that the foreign judgment/order sought to be enforced is res judicata under the laws of the relevant foreign jurisdiction; and
  • that the foreign judgment/order sought to be enforced is not contrary to judgment or order of a UAE court, and is not contrary to the morals and public order of the UAE.

The provisions of Article 85 are also applicable to arbitral awards issued in a foreign jurisdiction. Article 86 adds that the subject matter of the foreign arbitral award must be arbitrable according to the laws of the UAE, and the award must be enforceable in the jurisdiction in which it was issued, in order to seek enforcement in the UAE. Articles 85 and 86 are without prejudice to the provisions of any treaties entered into by the UAE with respect to the enforcement of foreign judgments, orders or awards. The New York Convention is an example of such a treaty.

Conclusion
Overall, the Regulations are directed towards quick and efficient litigation, and will be welcomed by parties and practitioners. However, they put considerable time pressure on litigants, particularly on defendants, to ensure that their respective cases are pleaded fully within relatively short time periods.

 

 

Screen Shot 2018-12-14 at 3.03.20 PM

http//: www.afridi-angell.com

Email: crandeniya@afridi-angell.com
Email: nhashim@afridi-angell.com

Related Articles by Firm
Merger clearance matters in the UAE
Despite the limited number of filings and the dearth of decisions, parties conducting M&A in or from the UAE should consider the impact of the competition regime.
New regulations offer welcome guidance to Anti-Money Laundering Law
The new AML Law has been shaped by international AML standards and provides several mechanisms to combat money-laundering.
Health data confidentiality on a rise in the UAE
A new law requires businesses that use information and communication technology for processing health data to ensure its confidentiality, accuracy and validity.
New Tawazun economic programme policy guidelines issued
It is hoped that the new programme will enable defence contractors to identify more accessible opportunities to generate offset credits.
New administrative fines imposed by the UAE Insurance Authority
Insurance and reinsurance providers should review the resolution and the list of violations to ensure their compliance.
New long-term residency visas in UAE
In a welcome development, the new law introduces long-term residency visas for four categories of persons.
New promotion regime for domestic funds
A new agreement could make the UAE a much more attractive place to establish funds.
Federal Penal Code amendments
The amendments are designed to make the UAE's Penal Code consistent with other recent federal legislation and current federal enforcement policies.
Netting arrangements made enforceable in the UAE
For decades, banks and other counterparties in the UAE have obtained financial services from foreign financial institutions. Industry bodies, such as the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA), the International Capital Market Association and the International Securities Lending Association, have ...
New anti-money laundering law
The new law introduces subtle but important changes to the AML landscape in the UAE.
The UAE's new Foreign Direct Investment Law
Majority foreign ownership is not yet a reality, but the framework is now in place.
Significant precedents from the DIFC courts
Afridi & Angell successfully defended an anti-suit injunction, an application to exclude evidence and obtained a document production order.
New services by Dubai Rental Disputes Centre
The Rental Good Conduct Certificate service is a first-of-its-kind initiative in the world.
ADGM announces tech start-up licensing regime
The licence provides access to a Professional Services Support Programme aimed at allowing entrepreneurs entry to a community of businesses, financial services and professional advisers.
Dubai relaxes rules on filing appeals before the Court of Cassation
The Decree provides that appeals to the Court of Cassation must be filed within 60 days of the judgment of the Court of Appeal.
Off-plan sales in Dubai: Risks and rewards
Whether buyers are looking to expand their real estate portfolio or buyers are simply looking to find their ideal home, great deals can be found in Dubai’s off-plan real estate sector ...
The UAE Federal Arbitration Law: A First Look
The approval of the long-awaited law by the Federal National Council was announced in March this year.
Legal reforms in Abu Dhabi
Abu Dhabi has introduced new rules governing the functioning of the Emirate’s judiciary.
UAE: Off-plan sales: risks and rewards
Great deals can be found in Dubai’s off-plan real estate sector, but it is critical that prospective buyers do their homework ...
The New UAE Pledge Law – Security Registration
UAE Federal Law 20 of 2016 introduced a new regime for registering a pledge over moveable assets which are pledged as security for the repayment of a debt ...
UAE VAT Designated Zones Defined
A Designated Zone is required to be a specific fenced area with security measures and Customs controls in place ...
Certificate of Good Conduct Required for all UAE Employment Visas
New requirement will be introduced shortly ...
Dubai: Dawn Raids – Do you have a policy in place, and is it fit for purpose?
How you handle a dawn raid will have a significant impact on the discussions and negotiations that are sure to follow.
Dubai: Changes to Law Allowing Developers to Terminate Off-Plan Sales Contracts
An important development that will assist developers who are facing a difficult real estate market ...
UAE VAT Executive Regulation Update: Free Zone Guidance
The UAE Ministry of Finance has announced the Executive Regulation for the Federal Decree-Law ...
Opportunities in Dubai’s Healthcare Sector
Dubai is the fastest growing healthcare market within the GCC and is becoming an increasingly attractive sector for investors. Afridi & Angell explain the key drivers and options available to investors ...
VAT registration in the UAE has commenced
The United Arab Emirates Federal Tax Authority has commenced accepting registrations for Value Added Tax through its online portal ....
UAE: VAT and Excise Tax
The UAE has issued substantive law on Value Added Tax (VAT) and Excise Tax ...
New Ministerial Decision brings clarity to Private Joint Stock Companies
The private joint stock company is one of the forms of company contemplated by UAE Federal Law No. 2 of 2015 concerning commercial companies ...
Be VAT ready - Tax Procedures Law is already here
Under the VAT regime, businesses will be collecting taxes on behalf of the government and will file tax returns accordingly ...
UAE – Centre for Amicable Settlement of Disputes update
Centre for Amicable Settlement of Disputes can no longer mediate disputes when a bank is a party to such dispute ....
New UAE Funds Regime
The UAE has embarked on an ambitious undertaking by introducing new business friendly mutual funds regulations to stimulate the UAE funds industry and provide the foundation for a more developed regional funds regime in the Gulf Cooperation Council ...
New UAE Pledge Law over Movable Assets
The new Pledge Law of the UAE was enacted on 12 December 2016 ...
Doing Business in Iran: Donald J. Trump; Mining Investment Opportunities
The election of Mr. Donald J. Trump as President of the United States has resulted in much consideration by corporates of existing strategies with respect to Iran...
The UAE Competition Law Clarified
Two Cabinet Decisions have been issued which provide guidance on the implementation of the Competition Law, particularly on market share thresholds and on small and medium establishments.
Potential Criminal Liability for Arbitrators and Experts in the UAE
The UAE Penal Code was amended to introduce the concept of criminal liability for arbitrators, experts, and translators who issue dishonest and partial decisions and opinions.
The New UAE Bankruptcy Law
Perhaps the most important new feature of the new Law is the introduction of a regime that allows for protection and reorganization of distressed businesses ...
Doing Business in Iran: The Momentum Builds
The momentum for doing business in Iran is expected to increase at an even greater pace after the November US elections.
Proposed Insurance Authority Decision Concerning Marketing of Insurance Policies by Banks in the UAE
The Emirates Insurance Authority prepared a draft regulation concerning marketing of insurance policies by banks in the UAE.
The thing about … Amjad Ali Khan
Recently in Dubai, ASIAN-MENA COUNSEL’s Patrick Dransfield photographed Amjad Ali Khan, the co-founder and Managing Partner of Afridi & Angell and also put to him a series of questions on behalf of the <...
UAE Ministerial Decision No. (272) of 2016
The Ministerial Decision No. (272) of 2016 addresses the scope of Article 104 of Federal Law No.2 of 2015, stating which articles relating to public and private joint stock companies apply to limited liability companies.
Doing Business in Iran: the banking bottleneck
With the easing of sanctions against Iran, vast business opportunities have opened up. The challenge is whether and how to participate in such a potentially phenomenal market without taking undue risks.
Doing Business in Iran: Life After (Secondary) Sanctions
The legal landscape for doing business in Iran has changed significantly since the easing of certain Iran related sanctions.
Doing Business in Iran: Life After (Secondary) Sanctions
The legal landscape for doing business in Iran has changed significantly in the past seven months ...
UAE Legal Bulletin
Updates on the possibility of a Value Added Tax, the new PPP Law and other developments which companies doing business in the UAE should know
UAE's New Labour Regulations Take Effect January 1, 2016
A number of recently announced initiatives could introduce potentially significant changes to the rules governing the workforce in the UAE.
Introducing the Dubai World Trade Centre Free Zone
Aside from its central location and its world class facilities, the Dubai World Trade Centre Free Zone offers a wide range of services for companies.
UAE Legal Bulletin July-August 2015
Insights into the new Commercial Companies Law and relevant corporate updates which can help companies conduct business in the UAE, particularly in Dubai
The New UAE Commercial Companies Law – A First Look
We highlight the changes which the new UAE Commercial Companies Law (Federal Law No.2 of 2015) introduces.
Do I need a DIFC will?
With the opening of the Wills and Probate Registry in the DIFC, it is now possible to register a will in Dubai and have a high degree of confidence that it will be enforced.
DFSA imposes record fine on Deutsche Bank
The Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA) imposes its largest fine to date on Deutsche Back AG Dubai (DIFC Branch), sending a strong signal that DFSA is both independent and unafraid to take on well-resourced opponents.
Abu Dhabi Global Market starts first phase of activities
Effective 15 June 2015, the Abu Dhabi Global Market began accepting license applications from existing non-financial service tenants of Al Maryah Island that have either a private limited or branch office legal structure.
Dubai Statistics Center – you may be next!
Companies in the Emirate of Dubai have recently been receiving questionnaires requesting detailed information about their business, including financial information...
Free Zones in the UAE – an overview
Strategically located between Europe, Africa and Asia, the United Arab Emirates has become a hub for trade and commerce throughout the world ...
UAE Competition Law - All bark and no bite?
Federal Law No. 4 of 2012 on the regulation of competition (the “Competition Law”) introduced a regime for the regulation of anti- competitive behavior in the UAE which previously did not exist ...
Related Articles
The Philippine Competition Commission bares its teeth
For the first time since its inception in 2015, the Commission has blocked a merger after conducting its review.
Bridging the Thai-Chinese cultural divide
China will soon become the leading foreign investor in Thailand, but there are still significant challenges for the unwary.
跨越中泰文化差异:寻找最佳法律合作伙伴
当她10岁随父母从中国移居泰国时,看到很多同时期的中国移民因为对泰国法律缺乏了解,投资受到重大损失。自此她矢志学习法律,立志帮助中国新移民跨越泰国的法律雷区,在泰国安居乐业。
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Global economic weather
Fed chairman Janet Yellen’s dovish comments after the Fed’s FOMC meeting persuaded the market that we can expect only two US rate hikes this year ...
Investigative Intelligence
Complying with global anti-corruption legislation: Conducting an internal investigation
The G20 Global Infrastructure Hub – First steps
The G20 has given the Sydney-based Global Infrastructure Hub only a four year mandate to realise its goal of closing the global infrastructure gap.
Latest Articles
The Philippine Competition Commission bares its teeth
For the first time since its inception in 2015, the Commission has blocked a merger after conducting its review.
Bridging the Thai-Chinese cultural divide
China will soon become the leading foreign investor in Thailand, but there are still significant challenges for the unwary.
跨越中泰文化差异:寻找最佳法律合作伙伴
当她10岁随父母从中国移居泰国时,看到很多同时期的中国移民因为对泰国法律缺乏了解,投资受到重大损失。自此她矢志学习法律,立志帮助中国新移民跨越泰国的法律雷区,在泰国安居乐业。