Asia (Other)

Screen Shot 2018-07-23 at 6.28.39 PMBy Cheng-Yee Khong and Tom Glasgow, IMF Bentham

Email: tglasgow@imf.sg
Email: khong@imf.sg

 

Cheng-Yee Khong and Tom Glasgow of IMF Bentham examine the new regulatory environment for third-party litigation funding in Singapore and Hong Kong.

 

Asia-mena Counsel: Last year’s article provided the basics of third-party funding and an overview of the funding landscape in Asia. Have there been any legal developments for funding in this region?
Cheng-Yee Khong / Tom Glasgow: The 2017 legislative changes in Singapore and Hong Kong to permit third-party funding in prescribed dispute resolution proceedings have provided certainty and guidance for parties, legal practitioners and funders in the dispute resolution industry.

In March 2017, Singapore abolished civil liability for the common law tort of maintenance and champerty and established a new regulatory framework to allow third-party funding for international arbitration and related proceedings, including court proceedings and mediations. Helpful, non-binding guidelines have been issued for funders, legal practitioners and arbitrators by the Singapore Institute of Arbitrators, the Singapore Law Society and the Singapore International Arbitration Centre respectively.

The regulatory regime has been designed with flexibility and party autonomy in mind, with relatively light statutory regulations focusing primarily on lawyers and law firms practising in Singapore. This approach, combined with its popularity as the seat of choice for international arbitration, has led to an emerging market for third-party funding in Singapore.

The first funding agreement under the new statutory framework was reported in July 2017. IMF agreed to fund its first international commercial arbitration in Singapore in February 2018, and there are more cases in the pipeline.

In June 2017, Hong Kong abolished maintenance and champerty for arbitration and related proceedings, including court proceedings, emergency arbitrators and mediations. The amendments apply to third-party funding of arbitration proceedings seated in Hong Kong, whether domestic or international, and in respect of work done in Hong Kong on arbitrations seated elsewhere.

It is hoped that the legislative amendments will come into effect this year, once a code of practice for funders is issued. IMF has received enquiries for funding in Hong Kong, which can move forward once this last piece of the jigsaw falls in place.

Any recent industry trends?
The costs barriers and associated risks of litigating are high in modern international arbitration as expenses are compounded by the international nature of the dispute requiring multi-jurisdictional and often specialist legal teams, as well as arbitrator costs, institutional fees and hearing costs. It comes as no surprise, therefore, that international arbitration has seen a rise in the use of third-party funding by parties with lesser means, or those who wish to level the playing field against a larger opponent.

However, dispute resolution finance is no longer just for those who are unable to pay. Sophisticated, well-resourced companies are increasingly seeking dispute finance: firstly, as an effective means to manage the costs and risks associated with complex commercial disputes by transferring all or part of these costs (including potential adverse costs) to the funder. Secondly, as a cashflow management tool and a means of raising corporate finance. General counsel and financial controllers have tight budgets and are increasingly seeking relief from burdensome litigation or arbitration costs to allocate funds elsewhere. More generally, a business may wish to leverage the value of its contingent litigation or arbitration assets by seeking funding in the form of a capital advance, with no corresponding balance sheet liability.

Screen Shot 2018-07-23 at 6.35.41 PMThese advantages are amplified when applied across a portfolio of disputes. In a portfolio, the funder’s investment can be cross-collateralised — linked to the overall performance of the portfolio rather than individual claims — and correspondingly risk is diversified. The reduction in risk may reduce the cost of capital to the funded party. A portfolio arrangement also allows greater flexibility to fund defence costs, as the funder can recover its costs and any return from the revenue generating claims within the portfolio. This means that businesses can obtain funding not only for bringing claims but also for defending claims brought against it.

Similar arrangements can be structured to support a law firm’s portfolio of contingency or success fee cases in jurisdictions such as US and China, where firms are permitted to act on this basis. The funder will assist the firm to meet its regular overheads as well as case-specific disbursements, in exchange for a share in the contingency or success fee generated by the firm.

What is the best way to select a funder?
Funders are not interchangeable. One important thing to keep in mind is that a dispute-financing relationship typically lasts two to three years until the resolution of the case, and will need to survive all the usual complications associated with any complex commercial dispute. This means that parties seeking funding, along with their lawyers, should look for a funding partner that has the track record, the financial resources and the know-how to serve as a trusted adviser and a partner who can go the distance when an unexpected turn in the case requires revisiting the litigation budget. Choosing a funder based on competitive pricing, whilst attractive at the outset, may not be the wisest choice when issues arise and remain unresolved, leading to delays and additional costs.

When choosing a funder, it is important to consider not just the funder’s track record for success, but also how long it has been in business to determine whether it has addressed thorny issues. Important factors to look for include whether the funder has been involved in disputes with funded parties or their lawyers; who will be dealing with the case at the company; whether interactions with the company will be with an individual who will approach the deal like a banking transaction, or a seasoned litigator who understands the fundamental nature of the litigation / arbitration at issue and can add value as it progresses. The source of the capital being provided is also important — is it readily available to draw down or does the funder need to make capital calls or go through other hoops to access it? IMF Bentham is comprised of experienced dispute resolution specialists who understand the cadence of the proceedings and how to handle obstacles along the road to resolution. IMF Bentham also has capital on-hand to fund legal fees, costs and even working capital and debt satisfaction for funded parties as soon as its diligence process is completed.

In addition to gauging a funder’s reputation, history and capital capabilities, the most successful funding arrangements are achieved when there is a mutuality of trust and respect between the funder, the funded party and the lawyers. Anyone considering dispute financing should have these goals in mind when first approaching a funder, to determine whether the funder is the right fit. It is imperative that all parties involved have a successful multi-year partnership with all interests aligned.

Screen Shot 2018-07-23 at 6.31.17 PMWhat are the steps to obtain financing?
We recommend reading IMF’s concise guide to funding, which sets out three key steps to finance a case and the basics of dispute resolution finance. A detailed description of the process from initial enquiry to funding follows.

Non-disclosure agreement (NDA)
Once the preferred funder is selected, the next step is to reach out with a general description of the case and the funding amount sought. Funders will invariably require a NDA before any substantive discussions occur. This is critical to the diligence process because it evidences the intent of the parties to maintain confidentiality and privilege over shared information.

Once a NDA is executed, parties should expect to have a more robust, but still preliminary, conversation with a funder about the case. In general, a funder will look for:

  1. a simple explanation of the case;
  2. where the case is pending (to verify there are no champerty or other restrictions in the jurisdiction);
  3. the anticipated funding amount sought; and
  4. the ideal funding arrangement (ie, whether the party is looking for working capital, legal fees, costs, or a combination of the three).

During these initial discussions, a funder will look to ensure that the matter meets its basic parameters. For instance, IMF Bentham typically requires a realistic damages estimate that is at least 10 times the proposed funding amount and a liability theory supported by documentary evidence. Typically, a party seeking funding will approach a funder with lawyers already engaged. In situations where a party seeking funding has not already retained a lawyer, funders are commonly willing to assist with making introductions and referrals if the matter satisfies the funder’s minimum criteria and the merits appear strong.

From the initial discussions, a funder should be able to generally understand the claims, the amount needed to fund the case to completion and a reasonable estimate of potential recovery. This information allows a funder to gauge its level of interest in moving forward. If that interest is strong, a funder will typically issue a term sheet that outlines the economic terms of the proposed investment and provides for a due diligence period to fully assess the merits of the case and related issues. For IMF Bentham, the term sheet is non-binding except for an exclusivity period, which generally lasts 30 to 45 days.

Funders require exclusivity because the diligence process is time-consuming and may require bringing on an outside expert to analyse the specific area of law at issue. Certain funders attempt to lock up parties with exclusivity requirements as early as the NDA stage, and often ask that parties reimburse them for costs incurred (eg, outside legal advice) as part of the diligence. IMF Bentham, in contrast, only requires exclusivity after the parties tentatively agree on terms. We also incur due diligence costs without seeking reimbursement from the party.

Indicative terms
A funder’s term sheet will invariably describe its proposed return structure. Returns typically (but not always) increase over time as the funder continues to invest risk capital in the litigation. There is no single way to establish up front what an acceptable return will be if the case is successful, and approaches vary widely. But it is often calculated as a multiple of the disbursed funding amount, a percentage of the litigation proceeds, or the greater of the two. One thing to look for is whether a funder proposes to take a multiple of the committed funding amount (as opposed to the amount deployed as of the date of any resolution). Often committed funds are not fully drawn upon if the proceedings do not go the distance, in which case committing to paying a multiple of the committed amount is inadvisable. IMF Bentham’s  business is focused on certainty and fairness. As such, we welcome early resolutions of the matters in which we invest — if fair to all concerned.

Screen Shot 2018-07-23 at 6.38.00 PMParties should also look at the proposed return priority structure. Generally, a funder will require a first-priority position to receive, at minimum, the return of its principal. If the claimant’s lawyers have agreed to a full contingency arrangement and the funding is for working capital, the lawyers may want input in such an arrangement. Addressing issues like these sooner rather than later will benefit all parties and help facilitate the positive relationship necessary to make a dispute financing partnership work.

Preparing a matter for funding
Funders put each potential investment through rigorous diligence, which typically takes 30 to 45 days. Given that a typical case might last over two years and involve a commitment of a few million dollars, a funder’s in-depth review is essential. This process includes meeting with the party seeking funding, reviewing relevant documents, and possibly hiring outside experts (especially if the case revolves around a highly-specialised area of law).

Parties should prepare for this process early. Funders will ask for pleadings that best summarise the legal and factual arguments from each side, and documentary or other evidence that both supports the claims and refutes any facially strong arguments from the adversary. A legally sound and objectively measurable theory of damages — even if preliminary — is important, and a pre-litigation damages analysis conducted by the lawyers or their consultants is a huge plus from a funding perspective. Funders will invariably seek access to the legal team to discuss liability and damages issues in depth. If the case involves a niche practice area that requires the funder to engage outside expert consultation, parties should ask whether this additional expense will be borne by the party or the funder when negotiating the term sheet. IMF incurs all such costs as part of its diligence process.

Preparing for and assisting with a funder’s diligence process may be time-consuming but it can be very helpful to strengthen the merits of the case, including identifying and shoring up any perceived weaknesses. Funders often reduce a case to somewhere north of its “worst-case scenario” and seek an explanation of the best arguments available. Lawyers are often very appreciative of the process because it forces them early on to analyse the pitfalls in the case, identify the best evidence available, and crystallise counter-arguments sooner than they otherwise would do in the litigation process.

While each case presents a unique set of issues, funders at a minimum look for the following in any investment opportunity:

  1. a cogent liability theory supported by documentary evidence, indicating strong prospects of success;
  2. a sound damages theory that results in sufficient damages to cover the funder’s return, the lawyers’ contingency stake (if any), and (in IMF’s case) enough remaining for the funded party to recover at least 60% of any award or settlement; and
  3. a high likelihood of collectability.

Being frank, realistic and dispassionate during the diligence process is important. Dispute finance is a multi-year partnership. Thus, it is best for everyone involved if the funder has the essential information to make an accurate underwriting decision. Once an investment decision has been made, parties can expect to finalise and execute a funding agreement.

 

Screen Shot 2018-07-23 at 6.24.55 PM

http//: www.imf.sg
Email: tglasgow@imf.sg
Email: ckhong@imf.sg

Related Articles by Firm
Recent developments in banking dispute resolution in China
New methods of financing and challenging economic conditions have fuelled new types of disputes ...
Recent Developments in Banking Dispute Resolution in China
This article focuses on the recent developments of banking dispute resolution in China ...
The Validity of Asymmetrical Arbitration Clauses
In the recent case of Wilson Taylor Asia Pacific Pte Ltd v Dyna-Jet Pte Ltd [2017] 2 SLR 362; [2017] SGCA 32 (“Wilson”), the Court of Appeal was invited to consider the validity of an arbitration agreement that only provided for one party to commence ...
The “Good Faith” Principle
Hong Kong Court of Appeal holds that the “Good Faith” Principle is Complementary to the “Choice of Remedies” Principle, Aligning Hong Kong Law with Singapore Law ...
What’s new with Cybersecurity in Singapore?
With the increasing frequency of cyber-attacks, the new Cybersecurity Bill could not have come at a more pertinent time ...
China: New Law Outlines Dos and Don’ts of Foreign NGOs
A newly ratified law, which takes effect on January 1, 2017, outlines how foreign NGOs should conduct their activities in China.
China's New Family Planning Law Changes Employees’ Benefits
China passed a new law, effective 1 January 2016, which encourages families to have two children and removed the right to extended leaves for those who get married or have children late.
Vietnam Client Alert - November 2015
Vietnam's National Assembly recently passed new laws which affect investments, real estate, employment, use of internet resources and sanctions on administrative violations.
China amends educational laws to enable private educational institutions profitable
China removes "profit" restriction and allows Sino-foreign cooperation in educational institutions effective 1 June 2016.
Vietnam Client Alert
This edition discusses new laws on overtime rules, corporate seals and use of IPRs in company names to the resolution of domain name disputes. Moreover, it presents an overview of how the new Trans Pacific Partnership will affect Vietnam.
Myanmar Opened its Broadcasting and TV Market
The Broadcasting Law 2015 opens commercial licenses for TV or radio for bidding under an independent supervisory authority. This offers wide opportunities to investors from broadcasting infrastructures to broadcasting services.
China Streamlines Commercial Registration System
Effective 1 October 2015, government authorities will no longer issue organization code certificate or tax registration certificate but consolidate their functions into new version of business license.
China Increases Standards of Reward for Transformation of Scientific and Technological Achievements
The newly revised Law on Promoting the Transformation of Scientific and Technological Achievements of PRC respects any reward agreement and provides default reward standards in the event of no prior mutually agreed reward standards.
Statutory Registration of Standard Terms and Conditions in Tanzania
All companies doing business in Tanzania should know the salient points of the Standard Form (Consumer Contracts) Regulations 2014 which takes effect on 29 December 2015.
Flurry of New Energy Legislation Proposed in Tanzania
The Tanzanian Government is in the process of a radical overhaul of regulations governing the energy and extractive sector.
Tanzania Bill Establishing the Petroleum Act 2015
Tanzania's proposed Petroleum Act 2015 introduces key changes to the Petroleum Exploration and Production Act 1980 and the Petroleum Act 2008.
Draft Implementation Rule Addresses Vague Issues in the Labor Contract Law
The recent draft Implementation Rule reveals Chinese labor authorities’ efforts to clarify vagueness in the implementation of the Labor Contract Law for the past years.
Cyber Security Law to Tighten Network Operators and Users Supervision
The draft Cyber Security Law aims to strengthen supervision over cyber security. The proposed measures will influence not only network operators directly but also users and all public sectors.
Shanghai's New Immigration Policy to Attract Foreign Talents
The Shanghai Public Security Bureau released the Implementation Rules on Series of Immigration Policies of Shanghai Sci-tech Innovation Center. The article describes the standards for foreigners to be identified as “overseas talents”, the conditions to apply for permanent residence and ...
Draft Law Outlines Dos and Don’ts of Foreign NGOs for the First Time
The second draft of the Law on Administration of Foreign Nongovernmental Organizations was published recently. The Draft Law defines foreign NGOs which refer to non-profitable and nongovernmental social organizations established overseas.
Tanzanian Energy Developments
Summary of the latest industry developments, as well as the country’s political developments, with a special focus on the Ministry of Energy and Minerals (MEM)
India: Latest Legal Updates for May 2015
Insights into the proposed New Land Bill, recent Supreme Court judgment on the principle of the arbitration agreement, proposed enhancement of the pecuniary jurisdiction of the District Courts of Delhi and other legal updates
SAFE New Regulation Promotes Discretionary Settlement of FIEs’ Capital Nationwide
The State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) released a circular on Reforming the Administration of the Settlement of Foreign Exchange Capital of Foreign-invested Enterprises which further promotes discretionary settlement of foreign investment enterprises’ foreign exchange capital nationwide. The circular take ...
Singapore: a snapshot of employment changes in 2014
The Singapore Parliament has rolled out a number of employment-related legislative changes.
Statutory paternity leave legislation in Hong Kong
From 27 February 2015, male employees in the private sector are entitled to three days’ paternity leave.
Preparation for annual individual income tax declaration for 2014 in PRC
Indivdual taxpayers with an annual income of RMB120,000 or more shall file an annual individual income tax return with the within three months of the beginning of the next year.
Shanghai clarifies labour dispatch rules
The Shanghai Municipal Human Resources and Social Insurance Bureau and Shanghai Superior People’s Court jointly issued the Meeting Minutes on Application of Law on Labour Dispatch on 31 December 2014.
China requires work visa for certain short-term work tasks
As of 1 January 2015, China has further tightened immigration requirements for foreigners coming to China for short term work tasks.
Ship arrest in China - Increased clarity from the Supreme People's Court
The Supreme People's Court of the PRC published the Regulations for Certain Issues Concerning the Application of Law Relating to Arrest and Auction of Ships which took effect on March 1, 2015.
Cabotage and its impact in Indonesia
Indonesia's shipping and offshore marine industry underwent major changes since the introduction of the Maritime Law No. 17 of 2008.
Oil price volatility - global employment issues
Amidst the oil & gas layoffs, the industry has to ensure that it has the manpower skills in place to respond to demand when oil prices recover.
Shanghai Court rules on SHIAC jurisdiction following CIETAC breakaway
Shanghai Court recently ruled SHIAC has jurisdiction on disputes arising from a clause referring the disputes to "CIETAC Shanghai Sub-Commission".
Oil price volatility - risks and opportunities in 2015
The sharp fall in oil prices amid deteriorating sentiment over the global economy has made investors weary of investing in other commodities.
Oil price volatility - legal issues in the E&P sector
With oil prices at their lowest for over five years, E&P companies and the governments of the countries where they conduct their exploration and production activities are now assessing their options.
The Singapore approach to scrutiny of arbitral awards
International arbitration must, out of necessity, rely on the courts to uphold and enforce arbitral awards and to support the arbitral process...
The new CIETAC Arbitration Rules 2015
The New Rules adopt both best practices and the latest developments in international commercial arbitration and accommodate the increasing needs of the parties arbitrating at CIETAC.
China’s Supreme People’s Court issues judicial opinion on work-related injuries
The Regulations define the general framework of work-related injury matters, including the scope of work-related injuries, verification of the injury, and obligations and liabilities of employers, amongst other aspects.
China’s plans to accelerate growth of insurance market
State Council's vision on bringing China's insurance industry into the modern age
China’s Supreme People’s Court issues judicial opinion on work-related injuries
As of 1 September 2014, the new judicial opinion of the China's Supreme People’s Court concerning work-related injuries (the “Opinion”) came into force
A watershed in the availability of corporate information in China?
In March 2014, the State Administration for Industry and Commerce launched the National Company Credit Information System (the NCCIS)...
APAC Employment Update
Employment updates from China, India, Japan, Thailand and Mongolia ...
Tanzania: energy market developments
Including: the impact of the August's US-Africa leaders summit; plus, an overview of the power utility giant, TANESCO,and its future in the Tanzanian market
Road infrastructure in Tanzania
The ability of Tanzania to upgrade and improve its road infrastructure will be one of the key factors in whether it can continue the impressive rates of economic growth ...
Tanzania: Impact of foreign exchange regulation amendments
The latest amendments to the foreign exchange regulations have relaxed and in some cases removed restrictions on inward foreign investment in the Dar es Salam Stock Exchange ...
India Update, inc. 'Building India through PPP'
This edition brings a featured article on Public Private Partnerships, as well as key judgements passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, changes in corporate and commercial matters and case laws in indirect taxation.
Enforceable obligation to be friendly: a new principle of law
A recent judgment from the Commercial Court in London established a new principle of law, in one of the cases brought by Clyde & Co’s dispute resolution team in Dubai ...
Employment law developments across the GCC
a summary of the key employment law developments across the GCC ...
An overview of medical malpractice in the UAE
With an increasing focus on regulation and reforms by local health authorities,there is evidence of a more litigious approach developing in the area of medical malpractice ...
Export Processing and Special Economic Zones in Tanzania
We examine the features and requirements of the EPZ and SEZ frameworks, set-out the differences and comparative advantages of each ...
Draft National Petroleum Policy of Tanzania
A look at the second draft National Petroleum Policy of Tanzania and ongoing energy market developments
Iran – plans for privatisation and reform in power sector
A look at the historical background to Iran’s power industry and how the latest developments will be transforming the way Iran manages this significant sector.
“Good Samaritan” principles in the UAE: legal liabilities when administering first aid
This article discusses whether a Good Samaritan principle is applied in the UAE, both from the perspective of rescuers and safety officers.
UAE Trade Marks Office puts an end to examination reports
On 19 May 2014, the UAE Trade Marks Office announced that it will no longer issue examination reports or grant extensions of time during the trade mark application process ...
Iran’s new Integrated Petroleum Contracts
Iran hosted an “Oil Show” earlier this month in Tehran. According to reports, over 600 foreign companies from 32 countries and over 1,200 Iranian companies attended ...
FDI laws in Libya
A stark reminder of the fluidity of the legal and practical landscape ...
The legal framework of the port sector in Tanzania
The port sector in Tanzania is one of the largest of East and Central Africa, serving Tanzania as well as the neighbouring landlocked countries of Malawi, Zambia, Democratic Republic of Congo, Burundi, Rwanda and Uganda ...
Registration of private sector foreign loans with the Bank of Tanzania
The Bank of Tanzania requires that all foreign loans from the private sector in Tanzania are registered with them. We look at what this registration means in practice.
What investors should know about Mexico’s new Energy Law
A significant step toward permitting private capital to support Mexican oil and gas production ...
Investigating procurement fraud in South and Southeast Asia
Markets in Asia can pose unexpected challenges for companies that rely on fraud mitigation and investigation practices applicable to developed markets. Quite simply, these practices do not work in Asia ...
Tanzania: Prospecting for and mining of radioactive minerals
New uranium mining projects have recently been announced in Tanzania. This briefing looks at the legislative framework surrounding radioactive minerals in Tanzania.
Public private partnerships in Tanzania
PPP's: an update following the Finance Act 2014
2013/14 Global Fraud Report
Kroll’s 2013/14 Global Fraud Report, prepared in conjunction with the Economist Intelligence Unit, surveyed 901 senior executives from around the world. This document includes an overview of the results and a thought piece on what the results mean for businesses globally. (...
The Tanzania Mortgage Refinance Company
This update looks at the development of TMRC to date and the products offered to Tanzanian banks.
The Chinese currency in the international financial markets
The rise of Chinese trade in Africa generally and Tanzania specifically is well known. China – Tanzania trade reached USD 2.5 billion in 2012 ...
Tanzania’s 4th Offshore Licensing Round: Key Terms
The 4th Tanzania Deep Offshore and North Lake Tanganyika Licensing Round was launched in Dar es Salaam on 25 October by President Jakaya Kikwete ...
Tanzania Security Fact Sheet
This month’s Tanzania update is a fact sheet recapping on the types of security available for different asset classes when taking security over corporate borrowers, with a more detailed focus on debentures and mortgages.
Related Articles
When disaster strikes – seven lessons in handling a cyber attack
Proper preparation and planning can help organisations set out a clear path for responding to a cyber breach ...
The Law on Cybersecurity and its effects on enterprises in Vietnam
Foreign service providers may be affected by a new regulation aimed at improving cybersecurity in the country ...
Is blockchain the answer?
Counsel need to be aware of the potential legal and other limitations of this rapidly evolving technology ...
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Market update and salary survey for the legal in-house sector in Asia
TAYLOR ROOT – ASIAN-MENA COUNSEL – 2015 market review and 2016 preview ASIAN-MENA COUNSEL is delighted to present Taylor Root’s tenth annual survey for the in-house legal sector in Asia. The findings offer valuable insights into the hiring trends and salary ...
Global economic weather – 11th May 2016
Asia: The economic news from Asia is currently conforming pretty much to trend, with occasional unexpected strengths, such as Japan’s industrial production last week or Australia’s exports this week ...
Latest Articles
The thing about … Carl Im
The brains behind eYulchon talks to Patrick Dransfield about his algorithmic approach to corporate compliance ...
New anti-money laundering law
The new law introduces subtle but important changes to the AML landscape in the UAE.