| As director of global investments in the legal and compliance team at Anbang International Holdings Goh’s recent transactions include the acquisition of several landmark hotels and office towers in New York, Toronto and Vancouver as well as Tong Yang Life Insurance, a leading listed Korean insurer.
We asked him about the role of in-house counsel in the M&A process.
Asian-mena Counsel: At what stage in the acquisition process should the in-house legal team start to be involved — before a specific target is even identified?
An experienced and commercially savvy counsel would be able to spot potential wrinkles — a smell test of sorts — and come up with various options or alternative transaction structures to minimise risk exposure and enhance the likelihood of success.
As the legal and compliance team is involved in all of our acquisitions around the world, we are able to draw upon the cumulative experiences and lessons learnt from all of these transactions when advising the local deal team in any particular country.
In a nutshell, instead of reinventing the wheel we can avoid the mistakes made on previous transactions and come up with a “new and improved” version of the wheel within a shorter period of time.
Having said that, these legal and compliance representatives have to “earn” the trust and respect of senior management and various stakeholders by demonstrating that they are reliable and commercially effective business partners. This has to be done on a consistent basis — you have to demonstrate value on each and every single transaction that you are involved in and justify your place at the table.
This is one of the key challenges that in-house counsels face and those who excel in this regard can quickly become an indispensable part of every transaction and a trusted sounding board for the senior management.
AMC: What are the key roles of the in-house legal team once a target is identified?
Even with external counsel on-board, the legal and compliance team should remain closely involved in every stage of the transaction. The legal and compliance team has a unique vantage point — we have a better understanding of the commercial drivers and other considerations behind each transaction, the corporate culture and inner workings of the company as well as the stakeholders whose approvals are required before a transaction can be consummated.
While risk management from a group perspective remains a key priority, the legal and compliance team should also facilitate and support the consummation of the transaction.
It can be a delicate balancing act. An experienced and commercially savvy legal and compliance team should be able to come up with options, alternatives and potential solutions instead of saying “no” all the time.
AMC: What about external counsel — what is the best way to manage their contribution?
One of the best ways to partner with external counsel is to have a candid discussion at the very outset and maintain an open dialogue with them throughout the transaction in terms of our and their expectations, whether in relation to the work scope, fee structure or any other issue that comes up during the course of the transaction.
Transactions, and especially multi-billion dollar cross-border M&A transactions, rarely progress in a linear fashion or as expected. Unanticipated events invariably occur and the way in which we work with our external advisers and recognise the sacrifices that they have made go a long way towards building a trusted and mutually beneficial relationship for subsequent transactions.
Every relationship is a two-way street — being respectful of and candid with external advisers, regardless of whether they have been retained on a particular transaction, is extremely important.
Treat external advisers the way you would like to be treated. The world is a small village after all.
AMC: Bringing it all together, what makes an M&A deal successful?
Having a good counsel by your side can mean the difference between a (painfully) successful deal and a successful deal that is fun and enjoyable.
AMC: What are some of the common pitfalls to avoid?
On the first point, there is a tendency to underestimate the complexity of a transaction when you have done similar transactions multiple times across various jurisdictions. However, each transaction is or will subsequently turn out to be unique in its own way and catch you off-guard the moment you start to relax and take your eyes off the ball.
On the second, cultural differences continue to play a significant role in international M&A transactions. While this has improved considerably over the years, the importance of spending sufficient time to gather information, explore differences in culture norms, and the other party’s perception of your team’s negotiation style cannot be over-emphasised.
Finally, it is extremely helpful, at the very outset, to establish core principles and your best alternative to an agreement. There can be a tendency to avoid drawing a line in the sand once negotiations have reached a fairly advanced stage. Knowing when to fold the cards takes a lot of courage and knowing your bottom line before negotiations commence can make a difference between happily-ever-after and a post-integration nightmare.
AMC: Are there any notable trends that you see in M&A among Chinese companies?
They are also likely to be more selective in their strategic and principal investments, and focus on sectors within or complementary to their core competencies.
Related Articles by Firm
Myanmar Opened its Broadcasting and TV Market
The Broadcasting Law 2015 opens commercial licenses for TV or radio for bidding under an independent supervisory authority. This offers wide opportunities to investors from broadcasting infrastructures to broadcasting services.
Clasis Law (India) Newsletter August 2015
Analysis of the revocation of a company's drug patent and other key court rulings and updates on corporate and commercial matters
The new CIETAC Arbitration Rules 2015
The New Rules adopt both best practices and the latest developments in international commercial arbitration and accommodate the increasing needs of the parties arbitrating at CIETAC.
Tanzania: Prospecting for and mining of radioactive minerals
New uranium mining projects have recently been announced in Tanzania. This briefing looks at the legislative framework surrounding radioactive minerals in Tanzania.
We talk to the legal vice-president for Nike Greater China about his role and the challenges of managing a China legal team for a high-profile multinational company ...
The thing about … Stefan Gannon
A decade after the global financial crisis, the Commissioner of the Hong Kong Monetary Authority’s Resolution Office speaks to Patrick Dransfield about the new legal regime designed to manage orderly bank failures ...
Robin Scott of City Mart Holding
Robin Scott discusses his transition to an in-house role in one of the world’s most exciting frontier economies ...
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
The new UAE Pledge Law
Promulgation of regulations that make registration available.
Exchange control laws of India: Compounding of contraventions
India has a complex exchange control regulatory mechanism that investors often find it difficult to comply with.
Corporate Social Responsibility
There is a growing realization among the corporates that business growth along with positive community/social impact is now an expected goal ...