Hong Kong

Hong Kong's skyscrapersThe Hong Kong Law Society is stirring controversy in the city’s legal community after claiming that foreign lawyers in the city are advising on Hong Kong matters “through the back door”.

The society wants to close what it sees as a loophole and impose tougher limits on the number of foreign lawyers that firms can hire and restrictions on matters they can advise on.

In-house lawyers who rely on the diversity of legal talent in the city have criticised the proposal. “The nature of Hong Kong as a global hub requires global expertise and talent to ensure quality of delivery,” says Carl Watson, general counsel of Arcadis Asia.

Carl Watson

Carl Watson

“This new rule is being sold as intended to prevent foreign lawyers from giving ‘back door’ advice on cases/transactions involving Hong Kong law — that is fundamentally going to back fire,” he continued. “Sure, if the issues are Hong Kong specific, no lawyer is going to risk taking a view if they’re not experienced or qualified. That is a professional obligation in any event. An insular, protectionist approach will diminish the credibility of the legal solutions we can deliver here and unnecessarily undermine the rich local talent by incentivising a quantitative rather than qualitative agenda in recruitment and development.”

Under a rule that has been in force since 1994, Hong Kong law firms have been required to employ one local lawyer for every foreign lawyer. But in a letter sent to law firms this month, the society has proposed increasing the ratio to 2:1. The proposal would also restrict foreign lawyers to only working on matters that involve the overseas jurisdiction they are registered in.

In response, according to the South China Morning Post, partners from 15 international law firms sent a joint letter to the society’s new president, Melissa Pang, reportedly expressing “enormous concern” that the proposal will have “colossal negative repercussions for the economy of Hong Kong and for Hong Kong’s status as an international financial centre”.

The proposed changes, which are open for consultation until the end of the year, would potentially affect 1,547 registered foreign lawyers in Hong Kong.

However, the move is seemingly at odds with the previous Law Society president’s position. As recently as March this year, Thomas So (who was succeeded by Pang in June) wrote: “We embrace diversity and welcome talent from other jurisdictions to join and strengthen our legal services sector. The current open regulatory regime for foreign lawyers achieves the right balance between ensuring free competition for all on a level playing field, maintenance of high professional standards and protection of clients’ interests.”

Restricting the ability of foreign lawyers to work in the city may also frustrate the city’s Financial Services Development Council (FSDC), which was set up in 2013 to promote Hong Kong’s development as an international financial centre — and is chaired by a Hong Kong barrister, Laurence Li, who first practised as a New York attorney and only qualified in Hong Kong in 2006.

One of the FSDC’s key goals is to position Hong Kong as a hub for work related to China’s Belt and Road initiative, which will not be helped by a proposal to restrict the ability of mainland lawyers to work in the city.

“The PRC is a huge stakeholder in Hong Kong and global businesses that its PRC entities invest in,” says Watson. “That investment requires PRC talent to be able to operate here.”

Related Articles by Firm
Clasis Law (India) Newsletter August 2015
Analysis of the revocation of a company's drug patent and other key court rulings and updates on corporate and commercial matters
Foreign Banks Allowed to Operate in Myanmar
After more than 50 years of banning, the Central Bank of Myanmar has issued the first final licenses allowing four foreign banks to operate in Myanmar.
Tanzanian Draft National Energy Policy of 2015
Highlights on the ongoing and upcoming industry developments with focus on the transition of the energy sector since the introduction of the Big Results Now! campaign
Mineral Rights Available in Tanzania
Overview of the mineral rights available in Tanzania, with specific focus on the various categories of mineral rights
The Legal Framework of the Aviation Sector in Tanzania
As attention turns to Tanzania’s trade and energy opportunities, the spotlight has fallen upon the nation’s infrastructure. This update focuses on the capabilities and issues of the Tanzanian aviation sector.
Oil price volatility - Offshore oil storage
Are there any legal concerns with tankers being used for floating storage?
Oil price volatility - risks and opportunities in 2015
While many companies can weather the oil price slide and volatility, some industry players face a real risk of insolvency.
India: Union Budget 2015
A bullet-point overview of changes in Direct Tax, Indirect Tax and Goods and Service Tax in India in light of Finance Minister Arun Jaitley’s first full-year Budget…
Prohibition against transfer of personal data outside Hong Kong
Section 33 of the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance (PDPO) prohibits the transfer of personal data to places outside Hong Kong, except in circumstances specified in the PDPO.
Security of payment under FIDIC contracts: more secure, for now
The High Court of Singapore recently handed down an important judgment in relation to the enforceability of Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB) decisions under the FIDIC forms of contract.
Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill passed as Ordinance in India
The long-awaited Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill has become a provisional law in India. The Bill amends the Insurance Act (1938), the General Insurance Business (Naturalisation) Act (1972), and the Insurance Regulatory and Development Act (1999).
SICC: now open for business
On Monday 5 January 2015, the Singapore International Commercial Court ("SICC") was officially opened...
Myanmar insurance update
Clyde & Co partner Michael Horn recently visited Myanmar's commercial capital Yangon and reports on the current state of the insurance market...
Launch of the online mining cadastre transactional portal
Plus, a summary of the key mineral rights available in Tanzania; and, a look at the manner in which mineral rights can be transferred.
Restrictions imposed on holders of mineral rights
This briefing looks at some of the restrictions imposed on holders of mineral rights in Tanzania by the Mining Act 2010
Draft local content policy for the oil & gas industry in Tanzania
The first draft of the long-awaited local content policy for the oil & gas industry in Tanzania has now been published by the Ministry of Energy and Minerals ...
Tanzania: Revocation of mining licences
The Tanzanian government recently announced the cancellation of a total of 174 mining licences. This mining update examines the key continuing obligations imposed by the Mining Act upon mining licence holders.
Mining Development Agreements
In this month’s mining briefing we look at Mining Development Agreements (MDAs) and the role that they play in the mining sector in Tanzania.
The Tanzanian railway system: current legal framework
The railway system of mainland Tanzania has a total track length of 3,676 kilometers (km) with two separate networks, run by two separate organisations ...
Related Articles
Malaysia challenges 1MDB payments to Abu Dhabi
It is applying to set aside an agreement to pay US$5.78 billion to an Abu Dhabi sovereign wealth fund.
IMF Bentham wins Singapore third-party funding agreement
Litigation funding has taken a step forward after a court ruled to allow a commercial funding arrangement to proceed.
CLOC holds its first gathering in Australia
The role of legal operations manager is an emerging one in Australia...
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
In-House Community Visionary Firm of the Year
Ten legal providers gave nominations for the Visionary Firm of the Year - Legal Services Award and the winning ...
Dispute Resolution Special Report
In this month’s Special Report on dispute resolution, we take a look at how Asia Pacific’s role as an international centre for dispute resolution, particularly arbitration, has grown against a backdrop of increasing cross-border transactions. As demand has ...
A seat at the table
Mitchell Stocks, General Counsel – Asia Pacific with US$3.5 billion technology company NetApp, shares his secrets to building a legal team in APAC from scratch, and how to ensure a seat at the table.
Latest Articles
Print Edition Subscription Form – Asian-mena Counsel
Asian-mena Counsel Print Edition Subscription Form
Creating an effective fintech IP strategy
Revised guidelines could provide opportunities to protect technology in this rapidly developing sector.
Significant precedents from the DIFC courts
Afridi & Angell successfully defended an anti-suit injunction, an application to exclude evidence and obtained a document production order.